Fan Cave Indy

Southside Indy's go-to sports card and Pokemon shop on Madison Ave. Organized by player and sport with accessible displays, Midnight Madness events, trade nights, and a focus on Colts, Pacers, and Fever cards.

Fan Cave Indy is a southside Indianapolis card shop on Madison Ave owned and operated by Parker and Jack Stevens, built for both sports card collectors and TCG enthusiasts. What sets Fan Cave apart is the way cards are organized — displayed by player, sport, or trading card game with high-profile loose cards accessible without having to peer inside a locked display case. Football is the biggest seller (Colts cards fly off the shelves), followed by basketball where Pacers players like Tyrese Haliburton and Benedict Mathurin are hot commodities. The shop has also capitalized on the WNBA boom, with Caitlin Clark and Indiana Fever cards becoming major draws. Pokemon is a focus on the TCG side, with sealed products and singles always in stock. Fan Cave hosts popular Midnight Madness events with special deals, grand prize giveaways, and multiple $50 gift card drawings, plus regular trade nights that bring the collecting community together. The welcoming, sports-talk atmosphere with live games on in the background makes this feel like your buddy's ultimate card cave.