Indy Card Exchange

Indianapolis's premier full-service sports card shop since 1990. Official PSA Authorized Dealer specializing in vintage and modern singles, wax boxes, autographed memorabilia, grading, and online breaks.

Indy Card Exchange is Indianapolis's flagship sports card destination and one of the longest-running card shops in the Midwest, serving collectors since 1990. Located on E 96th St on Indy's northeast side, the shop is an Official PSA Authorized Dealer offering in-store grading submissions that save collectors on shipping and insurance costs. The inventory spans all major sports — baseball, basketball, football, hockey, soccer — plus non-sport lines like Pokemon, Star Wars, and WWE from manufacturers including Panini, Topps, Upper Deck, and Leaf. Owner Andy Albert has built a community-first shop where collectors of all ages feel welcome, highlighted by the popular Kids Club program that introduces the next generation to the hobby. The iconic Michael Jordan bar where customers can rip packs is a fan-favorite feature. With eBay consignment services, online breaks, and a massive selection ranging from budget-friendly singles to high-end vintage, Indy Card Exchange is the definitive card shop experience in Central Indiana.