Monmouth Trading Cards — Oakhurst

The original Monmouth Trading Cards location on the Jersey Shore — a PSA Authorized Dealer offering sports cards, Pokémon, grading submissions, and community events in Monmouth County. The flagship that launched NJ's fastest-growing card shop chain.

The Oakhurst location on Route 35 is where the Monmouth Trading Cards story began. Situated in the heart of Monmouth County on one of the Shore's busiest commercial corridors, this flagship store established the template that has since been replicated across New Jersey and into Connecticut.

As a PSA Authorized Dealer, the Oakhurst location is a go-to destination for collectors looking to submit cards for professional grading without the hassle of navigating the process themselves. The team handles submissions for PSA and other grading services, offering guidance on which cards are worth grading and at what service level — an invaluable service for both new and experienced collectors.

The inventory follows the Monmouth formula: a wide selection of sports cards across baseball, basketball, football, hockey, and soccer, complemented by a robust Pokémon and TCG section featuring Magic: The Gathering and Disney Lorcana. Singles are displayed in an accessible gallery-style format that encourages browsing, while sealed product ranges from the latest releases to older hobby boxes.

The Shore location benefits from seasonal foot traffic during summer months, drawing vacationers and shore-house collectors who might not have a quality card shop near their primary residence. Year-round, it serves the Oakhurst, Ocean Township, Deal, Long Branch, and Asbury Park communities.

Trade nights and special events at the Oakhurst location maintain the community-first approach that defines the Monmouth brand. The store is open seven days a week with consistent hours, and the loyalty program carries across all Monmouth locations.