Randolph, NJ · Card Shop

All In One Collectibles

540 State Route 10, Randolph, NJ 07869
⚡ Pokémon 💎 Singles 🏆 Events
4.3
156 verified reviews
🏪
Is this your business?
Claim this listing to update your hours, photos, and connect with collectors.
Claim This Listing →

About The Shop

Northern New Jersey's collectibles leader — over 25 years serving Morris County with sports cards, Pokémon, Magic: The Gathering, Warhammer, comics, and more across a massive retail floor. Home of the Randolph Sports Card & Toy Show.

All In One Collectibles has been a Morris County staple since February 2000, when it first opened in a modest 600-square-foot space in Mt. Tabor. A quarter century later, the shop has grown into a sprawling operation on Route 10 in Randolph, offering a dedicated retail floor and the recently opened Battlegrounds Room — over 1,500 square feet of dedicated play space for events and tournaments.

The name says it all: this shop covers virtually every corner of the collectibles hobby. Sports cards span all major leagues with both sealed product and singles. Trading card games include Magic: The Gathering, Pokémon, Yu-Gi-Oh, and other popular titles with regular organized play events. The gaming side extends to Warhammer 40K miniatures, board games, and RPG supplies. Comics, both new releases and back issues, fill their own section alongside toys, action figures, and Funko Pops.

All In One Collectibles hosts the Randolph Sports Card & Toy Show in the Battlegrounds Room, bringing vendors from across the region together for buy-sell-trade events that attract serious collectors. The shop also runs weekly tournaments for various TCGs, making it a genuine community hub for gamers and collectors in the Route 10 corridor.

The atmosphere is welcoming and approachable. Owner Michael and his team are consistently praised for their knowledge across the full spectrum of collectibles and their willingness to help newcomers get started in whatever hobby catches their interest. A snack and drink selection lets visitors fuel up during long gaming sessions.

Conveniently located just minutes from Routes 80, 46, and 287, All In One Collectibles is easily accessible from anywhere in Morris, Passaic, or Sussex County.

What They Carry

Sports Cards
All major sports
⚔️
Magic: The Gathering
Tournaments & singles
Pokémon
Sealed & singles
🔫
Warhammer 40K
Models & paint
📚
Comics
New & back issues
🧸
Toys & Collectibles
Funkos & figures

Services

Buy/Sell/Trade 25+ Years in Business Randolph Sports Card & Toy Show Host Battlegrounds Room — 1,500 sq ft Play Space Weekly TCG Tournaments Snacks & Drinks Available Near Routes 80, 46 & 287 BBB Accredited — A Rating

Collector Reviews

★★★★★
Google Review
Awesome display of sports cards, comic books, Magic, Yu-Gi-Oh and Pokémon! The employees are knowledgeable and the customers are super friendly.
★★★★☆
Google Review
Good variety of everything collectible. The Battlegrounds Room is great for events and tournaments. Fair prices and friendly staff.
★★★★★
Google Review
I'm a baseball card collector but I have to admit the amount of comics, trading cards, board games, and toys here is impressive. Something for everyone.
★★★★☆
Google Review
Solid hobby shop that's been around for a long time. Great community events and a welcoming atmosphere for new collectors.
Status
● Closed Mon–Thu 12–9PM · Fri 12–9PM · Sat–Sun 12–7PM
Weekly Hours
Monday 12PM–9PM
Tuesday 12PM–9PM
Wednesday 12PM–9PM
Thursday 12PM–9PM
Friday 12PM–9PM
Saturday 12PM–7PM
Sunday 12PM–7PM
📍 Get Directions 📞 Call Now
🗺️
540 State Route 10
Randolph, NJ
📬 Newsletter

GET COLLECTOR UPDATES

New shop listings, card show dates, and hobby news — straight to your inbox.

Free · No spam · Unsubscribe anytime

🏪

Claim This Listing

Are you the owner of All In One Collectibles? Fill out the form below and we'll verify your business.