Just Collect

The nation's largest buyer of vintage baseball cards — headquartered in Summit, NJ. Over $50 million in sports cards and memorabilia bought and sold since 2006. Specializing in pre-war tobacco cards, vintage Topps, and high-end graded cards.

Just Collect is not your typical card shop — it's the nation's premier buyer of vintage sports cards and memorabilia, headquartered in downtown Summit, New Jersey. Founded in 2006 by Leighton Sheldon, a lifelong collector and Rutgers University graduate who bought his first pack of baseball cards at age eight and set up his first booth at a local New Jersey card show in 1989, Just Collect has purchased and sold over $50 million worth of vintage sports cards and memorabilia since its inception.

The Summit office serves as the company's headquarters and primary appraisal location, where collectors can bring their cards for professional evaluation. Just Collect specializes in vintage material — pre-war tobacco cards, Topps sets from the 1950s and '60s, high-grade vintage singles, and complete sets spanning every era of American sports card history. The team's expertise in accurately assessing condition and market value sets them apart from general card shops.

What makes Just Collect unique is its transparent buying process. Rather than relying on outdated price guides or offering blanket lowball percentages, the team uses real-time market data and actual recent sales to evaluate collections. They travel tens of thousands of miles annually to appraise and purchase collections across the United States and Canada, and they pay to ship insured collections to their Summit headquarters when travel isn't necessary.

Beyond buying, Just Collect maintains an active eBay presence and consignment service, helping sellers maximize the value of their collections through optimized individual listings rather than bulk sales. Vice President John, who joined the company in 2007, leads acquisitions and brings nearly two decades of expertise to every transaction.

For anyone in the NYC metro area or greater New Jersey who has inherited a collection, discovered cards in an attic, or is looking to sell a curated vintage collection for fair market value, Just Collect is the gold standard.