Cincinnati, OH · Card Shop

Hooterville Sports Cards

5120 Pleasant Ave, Cincinnati, OH 45014
⚾ MLB 🏈 NFL 🏅 PSA 💎 Singles 🕹️ Vintage
4.1
45 verified reviews

About The Shop

One of the longest-running sports card shops in the Cincinnati area. Massive vintage and modern inventory with individual cards, packs, complete sets, and hobby boxes in Fairfield.

Hooterville Sports Cards is one of the Cincinnati area's longest-running hobby shops, with nearly three decades of serving sports card collectors from its Fairfield location on Pleasant Ave. Owner Kevin Ashcraft has built an enormous inventory that spans vintage and modern collectibles — from individual cards and packs to complete sets and sealed hobby boxes. The shop is known among seasoned collectors for its deep selection, competitive pricing, and the kind of inventory depth that rewards repeat visits and careful browsing. Recent finds include hard-to-get Joe Burrow cards and vintage gems from the 1970s. The organized displays make it easy to browse, and regulars praise the knowledgeable staff who can talk cards across every era and sport. Hooterville is a destination for the serious sports card collector who appreciates selection and fair pricing over flashy presentation.

What They Carry

MLB Baseball
Reds & all teams
🏀
NBA Basketball
Modern & vintage
🏈
NFL Football
Bengals & beyond
🎥
NHL Hockey
Cards & sets
💎
Singles
Deep inventory
📦
Sealed Wax
Hobby boxes
🏅
Graded Cards
PSA & SGC slabs
🛡️
Supplies
Top loaders & sleeves

Services

Buy/Sell/Trade Massive Vintage Inventory Complete Sets Hobby Boxes Nearly 30 Years in Business Fairfield Location

Collector Reviews

★★★★★
Google Review
I have been coming into the shop for almost 30 years. The selection is top notch, the prices are very fair, and the staff is incredibly knowledgeable.
★★★★★
Google Review
A great local sports card store. Plenty of both old and new stuff, from individual cards to packs to boxes to complete sets.
★★★★☆
Google Review
Good selection and fair prices on vintage cards. Found a great 1974 Steve Spurrier and a recent Burrow. Definitely on my revisit list.
★★★★☆
Google Review
Massive inventory of sports cards from every era. The place rewards browsing and you never know what you will find.
Status
● Closed Mon–Wed 10AM–6PM · Thu–Fri 10AM–7PM · Sat–Sun 10AM–4PM
Weekly Hours
Monday 10AM–6PM
Tuesday 10AM–6PM
Wednesday 10AM–6PM
Thursday 10AM–7PM
Friday 10AM–7PM
Saturday 10AM–4PM
Sunday 10AM–4PM
Contact
📍 Get Directions 📞 Call Now
🗺️
5120 Pleasant Ave
Cincinnati, OH