Topps vs. Panini vs. Upper Deck vs. Fanatics: Card Brands Explained

The sports card industry is dominated by a handful of companies, and understanding who makes what — and who has which licenses — is essential for knowing which products matter. The landscape is also in the middle of a seismic shift as Fanatics takes over major league licenses from long-established brands. Here's the current state of sports card manufacturers and what it means for collectors.

Topps

Topps is the most iconic name in sports cards. Founded in 1938, they've been making baseball cards since 1951 and held the exclusive MLB license for decades. Topps flagship baseball, Topps Chrome, Topps Heritage, Bowman, and Stadium Club are among the most collected products in the hobby.

In 2022, Fanatics acquired Topps' sports card division. As of 2025-2026, Topps still produces cards under the Fanatics umbrella, but the brand's future role is evolving. Topps Chrome and Bowman remain flagship products for baseball collectors. For now, Topps remains the name most associated with baseball cards.

Panini

Panini America held exclusive licenses for NFL and NBA cards from 2009 through 2025, making them the dominant force in football and basketball collecting for over a decade. Prizm, Optic, Select, Mosaic, National Treasures, Flawless, and Donruss are all Panini brands that became hobby staples.

The Panini era is ending as Fanatics acquires these licenses. Panini's NFL license expired after the 2024-25 season, and NBA follows. However, Panini products from this era — especially Prizm — will remain the benchmark for modern basketball and football collections. A Panini Prizm Silver of a key player will be a recognized, traded card for decades regardless of who holds the license going forward.

Upper Deck

Upper Deck revolutionized sports cards when they launched in 1989 with premium card stock, holographic stickers, and higher production values. They currently hold the exclusive NHL license, making them the only manufacturer of officially licensed hockey cards. Upper Deck Young Guns rookies from the flagship set are the standard hockey rookie card.

Upper Deck also holds exclusive rights to Michael Jordan's autographed cards, making their MJ products highly sought after. They produce some non-licensed basketball and football products (without team logos) that have a niche following.

Fanatics

Fanatics is the new gorilla in the room. The e-commerce and sports licensing giant has acquired or is acquiring exclusive card licenses for MLB, NFL, NBA, and potentially more. They purchased Topps' card business and are building a card empire that will eventually control the majority of officially licensed sports cards in America.

What this means for collectors is still unfolding. Fanatics has announced plans for new products, digital integration, and direct-to-consumer sales. The hobby is watching closely to see whether Fanatics maintains the product quality and hobby shop distribution that collectors value, or whether they push toward a more mass-market, digital-first approach.

For now, the practical impact: expect new product names and designs over the next few years, and understand that the card brands you know (Prizm, Chrome, etc.) may change, rebrand, or be replaced. Collect what you love today — the cards themselves don't become less valuable because the manufacturer changed.

Leaf and Other Independents

Leaf Trading Cards produces non-licensed products featuring real players but without official team logos or league marks. Their products are generally less collected than licensed alternatives but can offer autographs and hits at lower price points. Other independent brands pop up periodically — some legitimate, some gimmicky. Stick with established manufacturers for most purchases.

Which Brand Matters for Which Sport?

Baseball: Topps (Chrome, Bowman, Heritage, flagship). The gold standard. Bowman Chrome for prospects.

Basketball: Panini (Prizm, Select, National Treasures) through 2025. Transitioning to Fanatics. Prizm Silver is the benchmark rookie card.

Football: Panini (Prizm, Optic, Select, National Treasures) through 2024-25. Transitioning to Fanatics. Prizm is king.

Hockey: Upper Deck (flagship, Young Guns). The only licensed manufacturer.

What Should Collectors Do During the Transition?

The Panini-to-Fanatics transition is creating uncertainty, but some things are clear. First, existing Panini products aren't going away in value — a Prizm Silver PSA 10 of a star player will always be a recognized, traded card. Second, early Fanatics products may carry premium interest from collectors curious about the new era. Third, the best strategy is the same as always: collect what you love, buy quality over quantity, and don't panic-sell because of licensing changes.

Your local card shop is the best source for real-time information on what's happening with product releases, brand transitions, and market shifts. Shop owners live this every day.

Back to: Sports Card Collecting 101 →