Indy Card Exchange
195 reviews
⭐ Top Rated
7035 E 96th St, Ste P, Indianapolis, IN
Hours
Tue–Thu 11AM–6PM · Fri 11AM–6PM · Sat 11AM–5PM · Sun 12–5PM · Mon Closed
Indianapolis's premier full-service sports card shop since 1990. Official PSA Authorized Dealer specializing in vintage and modern singles, wax boxes, autograph…
The Game Preserve
346 reviews
⭐ Top Rated
8487 Union Chapel Rd, Ste 660, Indianapolis, IN
Hours
Mon–Sat 10AM–9PM · Sun 12–6PM
Indianapolis's most beloved board game and tabletop store since 1980. Four decades of outstanding selection, expertise, and community — carrying MTG, Pokemon,…
Best Card Shop
64 reviews
2030 Stafford Rd, Plainfield, IN
Hours
Tue–Fri 12–7PM · Sat 10AM–6PM · Sun 12–5PM · Mon Closed
Plainfield's top-rated card shop serving the south/southwest Indy metro. Sports cards, memorabilia, sealed wax, loose packs, and singles with live breaks, a coz…
Fan Cave Indy
134 reviews
4805 Madison Ave, Indianapolis, IN
Hours
Tue–Fri 12–7PM · Sat 10AM–6PM · Sun 12–5PM · Mon Closed
Southside Indy's go-to sports card and Pokemon shop on Madison Ave. Organized by player and sport with accessible displays, Midnight Madness events, trade night…
Gray Gauntlet Games
87 reviews
7998 Centerpoint Dr, Ste 750, Indianapolis, IN
Hours
Tue–Sat 12–7PM · Sun–Mon Closed
A friendly local game store near Fishers offering Pokemon, Magic: The Gathering, Flesh and Blood, Warhammer 40K, board games, RPGs, dice, miniatures, paints, an…
Vintage Indy Sports
108 reviews
1450 Main St, Ste B, Indianapolis, IN
Hours
Wed–Sat 11AM–6PM · Sun 12–5PM · Mon–Tue Closed
Indiana's largest sports memorabilia store, located in historic Speedway. Specializing in Indiana high school basketball, Colts, Pacers, IU, Purdue, Notre Dame,…
The Game Preserve Southside
218 reviews
1551 E Stop 12 Rd, Ste B, Indianapolis, IN
Hours
Mon–Sat 10AM–9PM · Sun 12–6PM
The southside branch of Indianapolis's legendary Game Preserve. Board games, MTG, Pokemon, Warhammer, RPGs, and a large gaming space with regular events and a d…
K & L Cards
96 reviews
3100 Meridian Parke Dr, Ste Z, Greenwood, IN
Hours
Mon–Fri 11AM–6PM · Sat 10AM–5PM · Sun 12–4PM
Greenwood's trusted trading card destination for over 30 years. Football, baseball, basketball, Pokemon, Magic, and card supplies at the Meridian Parke Shopping…
Collector's Den
72 reviews
6214 Carrollton Ave, Indianapolis, IN
Hours
Tue–Sat 11AM–7PM · Sun 12–5PM · Mon Closed
A Broad Ripple neighborhood card shop on Carrollton Ave offering sports cards, Pokemon, comics, and collectibles in one of Indianapolis's most walkable, eclecti…
The Dugout
182 reviews
5707 W Morris St, Indianapolis, IN
Hours
Mon–Thu 12–7PM · Fri 12PM–12AM · Sat 11AM–6PM · Sun 12–5PM
A west-side Indianapolis institution since 1997, The Dugout is a hybrid sports card and gaming shop carrying basketball, football, baseball cards plus Pokemon, …