List with us

INDIANA Card Shop Directory

CARD SHOPS IN
INDIANA

The Crossroads of Card Collecting

37 Shops Listed

7 Cities

4.6★ Avg Rating

7,337 Total Reviews

Trading Cards in the Hoosier State

Indiana's trading card scene is fueled by the state's legendary sports passion. From the Colts and Pacers to the unmatched fervor of Indiana basketball at every level, the Hoosier State breeds collectors who take their cards as seriously as their game-day traditions.

Indianapolis anchors the scene with a growing cluster of shops serving the entire central Indiana corridor, while cities across the state — from Fort Wayne to Bloomington — add depth to the hobby landscape. The Indy 500, Big Ten athletics, and a proud baseball card heritage give Indiana collectors plenty to chase.

Whether you're hunting for Reggie Miller rookies, cracking the latest Pokémon set, or looking for a welcoming Friday Night Magic scene, Indiana's card shops combine Midwestern friendliness with serious hobby credentials. Expect fair prices, knowledgeable owners, and the kind of community atmosphere that keeps collectors coming back week after week.

Jump to: All Cities Indianapolis 16 Fort Wayne 8 Evansville 5 Bloomington 3 South Bend 3 Greenwood 1 Plainfield 1

Showing 3 shops in Indiana · 🏅 PSA Grading

🎴 🏅 PSA Grading ×

Card shows in Indiana · 32 upcoming

See the calendar →

Nov 1 Rift TCG Card Show — November 1 Indianapolis Nov 1 Master Ball Markets Brownsburg Nov 1 Card Show at The Eyrie — November 1 Plainfield

Indy Card Exchange

Indy Card Exchange

7035 E 96th St, Ste P, Indianapolis, IN

⚾ MLB 🏈 NFL ⚡ Pokémon 🏅 PSA 🕹️ Vintage 💎 Singles

Indianapolis's premier full-service sports card shop since 1990. Official PSA Authorized Dealer specializing in vintage and modern singles, wax boxes, autograph…

5432 E Indiana St, Evansville, IN

⚡ Pokémon ⚾ MLB 🏈 NFL 🏅 PSA 💎 Singles 🕹️ Vintage

East Indiana Street shop stacked with sports slabs, Pokemon and Lorcana — the most-reviewed card counter in Evansville and easy to browse.…

Upscale Trading Cards

3830 N First Ave, Evansville, IN

🏅 PSA ⚾ MLB 🏈 NFL 🏀 NBA ⚡ Pokémon 💎 Singles

North First Avenue shop built around graded cards — the only Evansville counter offering in-store card grading, plus UFC, WWE and soccer.…

📅 UPCOMING EVENTS IN INDIANA

Card shows, conventions, and tournaments happening across Indiana.

⚡ Pokémon TCG

Rift TCG Card Show — November 1

American Legion Kenneth N. Dowden Wayne Post 64 — Indianapolis

⚡ Pokémon TCG

Master Ball Markets

Brownsburg High School — Brownsburg

Card Show at The Eyrie — November 1

The Eyrie Event Space — Plainfield

🎪 Convention

Cards, Kicks & Collectibles Show — November 6 & 7

Precision Fieldhouse at Finch Creek — Noblesville

Indy Sports Card Show — November 7

La Quinta Inn Indianapolis — Indianapolis

⚡ Pokémon TCG

Collectors Palooza — November 15

Indiana State Fairgrounds & Event Center — Indianapolis

Lebanon, IN Card Show — November 15

Boone County Fairgrounds — Lebanon

JJ All Star Sportscards Show — November 21

Fishers American Legion Post 470 — Indianapolis

Carmel Sports Card Show — November 21

American Legion Post 155 — Carmel

Card Collector Fellowship

Hancock County Fairgrounds — Greenfield

Franklin Sports Card Show — November 21

Johnson County Shrine Club — Franklin

🔥COLLECTOR'S FEST 🔥

Lincoln Community Center — Highland

The Card Shop Finder is the national directory for trading card shops. Whether you collect Pokémon, MLB, NFL, or vintage cards, we help you find vetted local shops with hours, reviews, and directions. Explore more states below or browse the full national directory.