Louisville, KY · Card Shop

Sandlot Sports Cards & Collectibles

9327 New La Grange Rd, Louisville, KY 40242
⚾ MLB 🏈 NFL 💎 Singles 🕹️ Vintage
4.2
39 verified reviews

About The Shop

A collector's haven on New LaGrange Rd with sports cards, comics, and memorabilia. Owner John Joseph runs a passion-first shop that rewards patient browsing and repeat visits.

Sandlot Sports Cards & Collectibles is a passion project turned retail shop on New LaGrange Rd in Louisville's Lyndon area. Owner John Joseph has packed the shop with an eclectic mix of sports cards, comics, and memorabilia that covers decades of collecting history. The inventory is dense and constantly evolving, rewarding the kind of patient, thorough browsing that dedicated collectors love. Regular visitors know to check in frequently, as new stock appears regularly from collection buys and show pickups. The shop caters to baseball card enthusiasts especially, with a strong focus on both vintage and modern product. While the no-frills presentation is focused on the cards rather than the aesthetics, the depth of inventory and John's willingness to chat about the hobby make Sandlot a worthwhile stop for any Louisville collector who enjoys the thrill of the hunt.

What They Carry

MLB Baseball
Vintage & modern
🏀
NBA Basketball
Cards & singles
🏈
NFL Football
Selection available
💎
Singles
Deep inventory
📚
Comics
Back issues
📦
Sealed Wax
Boxes & packs

Services

Buy/Sell/Trade Collection Buys Vintage Baseball Focus Dense Inventory Lyndon Location

Collector Reviews

★★★★★
Google Review
I love this place. I stop by about once every other day buying baseball cards. Not only do I get the cards but I spend an hour just talking with the guy running it.
★★★★★
Google Review
Good selection of vintage and modern sports cards. You have to dig a bit but that is part of the fun. Fair prices on what I found.
★★★★☆
Google Review
A collector's shop through and through. The inventory is dense and rewards repeat visits. John knows his stuff.
★★★★☆
Google Review
Not the fanciest shop but the stock is deep. Great for baseball card collectors who enjoy browsing.
Status
● Closed Tue–Fri 10AM–7PM · Sat 10AM–6PM · Sun–Mon Closed
Weekly Hours
Monday Closed
Tuesday 10AM–7PM
Wednesday 10AM–7PM
Thursday 10AM–7PM
Friday 10AM–7PM
Saturday 10AM–6PM
Sunday Closed
Contact
📍 Get Directions 📞 Call Now
🗺️
9327 New La Grange Rd
Louisville, KY