The Mount Kisco Card & Memorabilia Show returns to the Boys & Girls Club of Northern Westchester on Sunday, September 13, 2026, from 9:00 AM to 3:00 PM. Promoted by Michael Demaio, this is a traditional Sunday sports card show in the classic mold: more than 70 dealer tables, a 5 dollar admission, a community venue, and a room full of regulars who have been buying and selling here for years. For collectors in Westchester, Putnam, and southern Connecticut it is the closest full-size sports show, and it draws dealers from across the tri-state area.
Sports cards are the heart of the show. Expect strong baseball inventory, from vintage Topps and Bowman through modern Chrome and Prizm, plus basketball, football, and hockey singles, rookies, autographs, and graded slabs from PSA, BGS, and SGC. Memorabilia is the second pillar, with signed balls, photos, jerseys, and game-used pieces, and the show typically has authentication-conscious dealers who can walk you through provenance. A handful of tables carry Pokemon and other TCGs, and there is usually a supplies vendor, but this is a sports-first room.
The show runs 9:00 AM to 3:00 PM with no separate early bird tier; the first hour is when the serious buyers work the room. Admission is 5 dollars at the door, and the club setting keeps things family-friendly, so kids are welcome. Dealers here actively buy collections, and Sunday morning is a good time to bring one in.
The Boys & Girls Club is at 351 Main Street in Mount Kisco, a short walk from the Mount Kisco Metro-North station on the Harlem Line, which makes this one of the few Westchester shows reachable without a car. If you drive, the club has its own lot and there is municipal parking nearby; Saw Mill River Parkway and Route 117 bring you in from either direction. Main Street has plenty of cafes and delis for a mid-morning break.
Who should attend: vintage baseball collectors, set builders hunting commons and stars in one stop, autograph and memorabilia buyers who want to inspect items in person, parents introducing kids to the hobby, and dealers looking for a well-established monthly-style show with a reliable crowd. First-timers will find it welcoming and easy to navigate.
Tips: come at 9:00 AM sharp for the best selection, bring cash because most dealers price for it, and bring a list of the specific cards or players you are chasing. If you are selling, bring your best material organized and priced so dealers can make quick offers. The show repeats on November 15, 2026 at the same venue. For table reservations or questions, contact Michael Demaio at 914-874-6805. The show has a long track record at this venue, and many of its dealers have been setting up here for a decade or more, so the pricing tends to be fair and consistent; regulars say it is one of the better rooms in the region for vintage baseball at honest numbers.