PSA vs BGS vs CGC: Which Grader Should You Use?
A head-to-head comparison of PSA, BGS, and CGC — cost, turnaround, subgrades, resale premium, and which grader wins for each category.
PSA dominates market share and resale premium. BGS has loyal fans for subgrades and high-end modern. CGC has taken over large chunks of the Pokemon market. Picking the right grader depends on what you're submitting, how fast you need it back, and where you plan to sell.
The Three Majors at a Glance
PSA (Professional Sports Authenticator) is the oldest and largest. Grading scale 1–10 with half-point grades from 1.5 to 8.5, no subgrades. Their slabs are the market standard — PSA commands higher resale prices than any other holder across most categories.
BGS (Beckett Grading Services) offers subgrades — four separate scores (centering, corners, edges, surface) that average into the final grade. A BGS Pristine 10 "Black Label" (all four subgrades 10) is one of the most prestigious designations in the hobby. Strong in modern basketball, football, and high-end Pokemon.
CGC (Certified Guaranty Company) expanded from comics to cards around 2020 and has become the main alternative to PSA for Pokemon. Half-point grades, fast turnaround, and competitive pricing. Sports market share is growing but still trails PSA. Its top grade is split in two: Gem Mint 10, and above it Pristine 10 for cards that are essentially flawless under magnification. They are different markets, so compare a CGC price to the right one: CGC reports that only seven of the 1,275 1st Edition Neo Genesis Lugias it has graded are Pristine 10, and one sold for $100,100 on eBay in March 2026.
By Category
Vintage sports: PSA or SGC. SGC's tuxedo holder is a favorite for pre-war.
Modern sports: PSA for resale premium. BGS competitive on high-end with subgrades.
Pokemon (modern): CGC for speed and cost; PSA 10 still usually sells for more (see below).
Pokemon (vintage/WOTC): PSA rules here. On WOTC-era cards the PSA 10 premium over a CGC 10 is frequently 50–100% or more.
Magic: The Gathering: BGS and CGC dominate. MTG collectors are subgrade-focused.
Cost and Turnaround
PSA closed its four Value tiers to new submissions on June 2, 2026, and its cheapest open level is now Standard: $59.99 a card and 90–100 business days, from September 14 (PSA's announcement, reported by SI). Priority is $79.99 for 70–80 business days and Express $199 for 20–30. Our PSA turnaround guide has every level.
CGC is now both cheaper and faster at the low end. On October 8, 2026 its services page listed Bulk at $17 a card (25-card minimum, 150 working days), Economy at $20 (90 working days), Standard at $55 (10 working days) and Express at $100 (5 working days).
BGS and SGC, which are owned by PSA's parent company, Collectors, lengthened their turnarounds this year too; SGC had gone from 15–20 to 40–50 days by late May (SI, May 28).
The Resale Question
Across most categories PSA carries a 20–50% premium over BGS or CGC on the same card in the same grade. On Pokémon the size of the gap depends on the era: Pokémon Price Tracker's August 2026 comparison put the PSA 10 premium over CGC 10 at roughly 25–60% on modern chase cards and frequently 50–100% or more on vintage WOTC-era cards.
So for sports and vintage cards you plan to sell, PSA is almost always the right call. For modern Pokémon, compare recent sold prices in both slabs, and both companies' fees, before you submit; our is grading worth it guide has the break-even math.
The Subgrade Debate
BGS subgrades give precise condition information. They matter hugely on top-end cards where the Black Label premium can be 10x. They matter less on middle-market cards. PSA and CGC don't offer subgrades.
What About SGC?
SGC is the fourth major grader, especially strong for vintage sports. Their black tuxedo holders are respected, particularly on pre-war. SGC has been owned by Collectors, PSA's parent company, since early 2024 (Sports Collectors Digest), though it still grades under its own name. For vintage baseball, SGC is a legitimate PSA alternative at often better prices.
Decision Framework
What are you grading? Vintage sports → PSA/SGC. Modern Pokemon → CGC or PSA, by recent comps. Vintage Pokemon → PSA. Modern sports → PSA. MTG → BGS/CGC.
Is resale a priority? Yes → PSA. No → cheapest reliable option for your category.
How fast? Urgent → CGC Express or Standard, or PSA Express. Normal → CGC Economy or PSA Standard; at the time of writing CGC Standard ($55, 10 working days) is far quicker than PSA Standard ($59.99, 90–100 business days).
Need a shop for grading submissions?
310 of the 1,734 shops in our directory are tagged for PSA grading help, and many of them batch customer cards into one submission, which saves each customer the inbound shipping.