Simi Sportscards

Erringer Road's PSA-dealer sports card shop in Simi Valley, buying full collections and grading submissions alongside sealed wax and vintage.

Simi Sportscards opened its doors on Erringer Road in March 2023 and has built a BBB-accredited, A-plus reputation in a relatively short window - a track record that matters in a hobby where trust around grading and collection buying can make or break a shop's name. The unit sits in a small retail row a few minutes from the 118, easy to find for anyone searching for a sports card shop in Simi Valley rather than driving into LA.

The case here runs modern and vintage sports cards side by side: sealed wax boxes from Topps, Panini, Upper Deck, and Leaf share shelf space with vintage singles and a growing Pokemon section. As a registered PSA dealer partnered with Level Up Subs, the shop handles grading submissions in-house rather than sending customers elsewhere, which shortens the loop for anyone trying to get a pull authenticated and slabbed.

Collection buying is the other pillar of the business - "We BUY Collections" isn't just a sign in the window, it's a steady part of how the shop restocks its case, and the team also runs a consignment program for sellers who'd rather list through the shop than deal with it themselves. Beyond the physical counter, Simi Sportscards runs live breaks and sales through Whatnot, giving collectors who can't make it in person a way to shop the same inventory.

Hours run noon to 7pm Monday through Friday and 11am to 5pm on Saturday, with the shop closed Sundays - plan a weekday evening or Saturday morning visit.

Whether you're chasing vintage singles, a fresh PSA submission, or just a spot to sell a shoebox of cards, Simi Sportscards is one of the more established options for trading cards in Simi Valley.