The JJ All Star Sportscards Show returns to Fishers American Legion Post 470 on Saturday, September 19, 2026, bringing the Indianapolis metro's most reliable free-admission monthly card show into the heart of football season. September is one of the best months on the hobby calendar — NFL and college football are in full swing, baseball's pennant races are heating up, and basketball and hockey product is hitting shelves — making this a high-energy buying day for collectors of every stripe. Hosted by promoter Jeff Meyrose, the show fills a comfortable single-level room with vendor tables and steady traffic from across central Indiana and neighboring states.
The vendor floor packs an impressive slice of the hobby. Sports card dealers stock deep MLB, NBA, NFL, NHL, UFC, boxing, and soccer inventory across every era — vintage Topps, Bowman, and Fleer from the 1950s through the 1980s, junk-wax 1990s staples, and modern Panini Prizm, Donruss Optic, Select, Topps Chrome, Bowman Draft, and premium National Treasures, Flawless, and Immaculate. With football season underway, expect heavy Indianapolis Colts and college inventory across Notre Dame, Indiana, and Purdue, plus strong Cincinnati Reds, Chicago Cubs, Chicago Bears, and Detroit-area product reflecting the regional fan base. TCG tables carry Pokemon singles and sealed from vintage WOTC Base Set, Jungle, and Fossil through modern Scarlet & Violet hits and Japanese imports, plus Magic: The Gathering Commander and Standard, Yu-Gi-Oh! vintage and modern, One Piece, Disney Lorcana, Dragon Ball Super, and Digimon. Graded slabs from PSA, BGS, SGC, and CGC fill multiple locked cases, alongside autographed memorabilia, Funko Pops, vintage comics, and hobby supplies.
Show hours run 8:00 AM to 2:00 PM EDT. Admission is completely free, parking in the American Legion lot is free, and door prizes are typically distributed throughout the morning while supplies last. Kids are welcomed and encouraged, and the post lounge usually has snacks and beverages available.
Fishers American Legion Post 470 is located at 9091 East 126th Street, Fishers, IN 46038, just off Allisonville Road and a quick hop from I-69 — easy to reach from downtown Indianapolis, Carmel, Noblesville, and Westfield. The venue is climate-controlled, ADA-accessible, and laid out for easy aisle navigation. The 116th Street corridor and Hamilton Town Center restaurants are perfect for a pre- or post-show meal.
This show fits a wide range of collectors. Serious buyers arrive at 8:00 AM sharp to cherry-pick vintage and modern high-end before the morning rush. Flippers and breakers restock binders and swap case-break hits at fair local pricing. Families love the free-entry model — kids regularly walk the floor with pocket money picking up dime-bin singles, common Pokemon cards, and their first graded slabs. TCG players scout singles for upcoming League Cups and Regional Championship Qualifiers.
For the best experience, arrive right at 8:00 AM for the freshest inventory, bring cash in small bills with Venmo and Zelle as backup, and carry a want list, penny sleeves, top loaders, and a carrying box. Walk the full floor before buying and save the last hour for negotiation — dealers usually cut prices on borderline inventory rather than haul it home. For table reservations contact Jeff Meyrose at 317-504-8110, and follow JJ All Star Sportscards on Facebook and Instagram for vendor previews and the rest of the 2026 calendar.