Home › MLB Baseball Card Shops › New Jersey
MLB Baseball Cards · NJ

MLB Baseball Cards Card Shops in New Jersey

Find local mlb baseball cards card shops in New Jersey — browse hours, ratings, Street View photos, and directions for every listed shop.

8Shops in New Jersey
8Cities Covered
AberdeenMost Shops

There are 8 MLB Baseball Cards card shops listed in New Jersey, spread across 8 cities including Aberdeen, East Brunswick, and East Hanover. Highest-rated currently: East Coast Connection in Lyndhurst.

Baseball cards built the modern hobby, and they remain the deepest specialty category in most card shops. The MLB-focused shops listed below stock current Topps and Bowman product, vintage stars from the 50s through the 80s, and modern rookies — plus the supplies and showcase cases that serious sets demand.

Top MLB Baseball Cards Shops

Highest-rated shops in our directory carrying mlb baseball cards.

View all 8 →
East Coast Connection storefront
East Coast Connection
142 reviews
⭐ Top Rated
304 Ridge Rd, Lyndhurst, NJ
⚾ MLB 🏈 NFL ⚡ Pokémon 🕹️ Vintage
Hours
Mon–Fri 10:30AM–5:30PM · Sat 10AM–3PM · Sun Closed
● Open
(201) 438-4327 View Shop →
Just Collect storefront
Just Collect
97 reviews
★4.8
39 Park Ave, Summit, NJ
⚾ MLB 🏅 PSA 🕹️ Vintage 💎 Singles
Hours
By Appointment
● Closed
(908) 598-0071 View Shop →
Evan's Sports Cards & Collectibles storefront
Evan's Sports Cards & Collectibles
203 reviews
★4.7
2999 E Evesham Rd, Voorhees, NJ
⚾ MLB 🏈 NFL 🏅 PSA 💎 Singles
Hours
Tue–Sat 10AM–6PM · Sun 12–5PM · Mon Closed
● Closed
(856) 489-1800 View Shop →
The Hobby Shop storefront
The Hobby Shop
215 reviews
★4.6
1077-C State Hwy 34, Aberdeen, NJ
⚾ MLB ⚡ Pokémon 💎 Singles
Hours
Mon–Tue 12–6PM · Wed–Fri 10AM–8PM · Sat 10AM–6PM · Sun 10AM–5PM
● Open
(732) 583-0505 View Shop →
The Hobby Hive storefront
The Hobby Hive
89 reviews
★4.6
30 Ridgedale Ave, East Hanover, NJ
⚾ MLB 🏈 NFL ⚡ Pokémon 💎 Singles
Hours
Check website for current hours
● Closed
— View Shop →
Monmouth Trading Cards — Oakhurst storefront
Monmouth Trading Cards — Oakhurst
134 reviews
★4.5
1604 NJ-35, Oakhurst, NJ
⚾ MLB 🏈 NFL ⚡ Pokémon 🏅 PSA
Hours
Sun–Fri 10AM–6PM · Sat 10AM–6PM
● Open
(973) 494-8062 View Shop →
Temdee Collectibles storefront
Temdee Collectibles
131 reviews
★4.4
5051 Route 42, Turnersville, NJ
⚾ MLB 🏈 NFL 🕹️ Vintage 💎 Singles
Hours
Mon–Fri 12–6PM · Sat 12–6PM · Sun 12–4:30PM
● Open
(856) 228-8645 View Shop →
Monmouth Trading Cards — East Brunswick storefront
Monmouth Trading Cards — East Brunswick
118 reviews
★4.4
739 NJ-18, East Brunswick, NJ
⚾ MLB 🏈 NFL ⚡ Pokémon 🏆 Events
Hours
Mon–Sun 11AM–7PM
● Open
(732) 993-7002 View Shop →

MLB Baseball Cards Card Shops by City in New Jersey

Cities with the most shops carrying mlb baseball cards in New Jersey.

Aberdeen, NJ 1 East Brunswick, NJ 1 East Hanover, NJ 1 Lyndhurst, NJ 1 Oakhurst, NJ 1 Summit, NJ 1 Turnersville, NJ 1 Voorhees, NJ 1

Frequently Asked Questions

What kinds of baseball cards do these shops carry?
Most carry the full range — current-year Topps and Bowman, modern rookies, vintage stars, graded slabs, supplies, and often sealed product for case breaks.
Do baseball card shops sell graded cards?
Yes — most shops with showcase cases stock graded singles from PSA, BGS, SGC, and CSG. The shops tagged with "PSA" specifically may also accept grading submissions on your behalf.
When is the best time to visit for fresh inventory?
Mid-week is usually best — shops process weekend buy-ins on Monday and Tuesday, so by Wednesday the singles binders and showcase cases have new pulls.
Are there baseball card shops that buy collections?
Nearly all do. Bring a list of your top cards (player, year, condition, set), plus photos for anything you think is valuable. Call ahead for large estates.
Stay In The Loop

SUBSCRIBE TO OUR
NEWSLETTER

New shop listings, card show dates, hobby news, and exclusive collector insights — delivered to your inbox. No spam, just cardboard.

I collect:

Free forever · Unsubscribe anytime · No spam