Available on eBay
3 live listings
38% under
10% under
30% under
Price history
Oct 7, 2026 – Oct 24, 2026Median asking price of the live eBay listings we track for this card, one snapshot a day: 17 days from Oct 7, 2026 to Oct 24, 2026. Asking prices, not sold prices; 35 days whose listings were clearly a different product are left out.
About Nightmare
Nightmare is a Rare Magic: The Gathering card from the Alpha Edition set (card #N/A). Its current market price is $1,399.99, placing it among the higher-value cards collectors chase.
How much is Nightmare worth?
As of the latest update, Nightmare carries a market value of about $1,399.99. Over the past week the price has held steady, and it has been relatively flat over the last month.
Nightmare by the numbers
- On eBay, the median asking price of the listings we track was $974.79 on Oct 24, 2026. Across 17 daily snapshots since Oct 7, 2026 it ranged from $920.87 to $974.79.
- 3 eBay listings are live today, asking $869.99 to $1,265.00.
- Nightmare ranks #9 by price among the 17 Alpha Edition cards we price.
Should you buy or sell Nightmare?
Nightmare has been holding a steady price, making it easier to gauge a fair deal whether you're buying or selling. Either way, a local card shop can give you an in-hand assessment, and our buying & selling guide covers how to get a fair price.