Seven-day-a-week Greenville card shop where Pokemon singles and graded sports slabs share the same counter, with market-priced buying that regulars trust.
Open every single day of the week — a rarity in this hobby — Catch 'Em All Cards sits on North Pleasantburg Drive just north of Haywood Road, in a strip that makes it an easy stop on the way in or out of downtown. The storefront is compact and card-first: no board game tables, no arcade cabinets, just cases, boxes, and product. That focus is the point. This is a Greenville card shop built for people who came in to buy or sell cards, not to hang out for six hours.
The split between sports and Pokemon is genuinely even, which is unusual. One side of the shop runs modern and vintage baseball, football, and basketball — raw singles in monster boxes, graded slabs under glass, sealed hobby product behind the counter. The other side handles Pokemon cards Greenville collectors are hunting: English and Japanese sets, single card binders, ETBs, and a rotating selection of sealed. The owners are PSA dealers and handle grading submissions in-house, so you can hand off a stack of raw cards instead of packaging your own bubble mailer.
What customers repeat most often in reviews is the pricing transparency. Buy offers are pulled from live comps rather than a gut number, and staff will show you the sales data they're working from. For anyone who has been lowballed at a shop before, that alone is worth the drive. Trade-ins get the same treatment.
Hours are generous: 10am to 7pm Monday through Friday, and an early 9am open on both Saturday and Sunday. Weekend mornings are the quietest window if you want real time at the counter or a serious collection appraisal. Afternoons pick up considerably, especially after a new set release.
Parking is directly in front of the unit and there's no meter to feed. If you're bringing in a large lot to sell, calling ahead is worth the two minutes — the team will set aside time to go through it properly rather than rushing you at a busy counter.
