Teammates Sports Cards and Collectibles

Standiford Avenue card shop split down the middle — sports cards and slabs on one side, a deep Pokemon and MTG wall on the other.

Teammates Sports Cards and Collectibles is the kind of Modesto card shop that started in sports and grew into TCG without losing the original soul. Walk in off Standiford Ave and the layout tells the whole story: the left side is wall-to-wall sports — graded baseball slabs, monster boxes of football and basketball, autographed memorabilia in a locked display — while the right side is dedicated to Pokemon, Magic: The Gathering, and Yu-Gi-Oh singles, sealed boxes, and supplies.

The shop is well-organized, which matters more than it sounds. Singles are sorted by set rather than dumped into communal binders, and sealed Pokemon product is shelved by recent release rather than crammed into a vault. Staff stay on the floor to help you locate specific cards rather than waving you toward the singles wall and disappearing. Teammates is also known for one of the larger TCG sealed inventories in the Central Valley, with hobby boxes and ETBs in stock when most regional shops have sold through.

For sports collectors, the trade-in counter is the draw. Bring a collection in and they'll work through it card by card, with cash or store-credit offers explained transparently. They also handle PSA grading submissions, which saves Modesto-area collectors the headache of running their own bulk-submission paperwork. Memorabilia consignment is available for higher-end items.

Hours skew toward standard retail — Monday through Friday late morning into early evening, with a shorter Saturday and Sunday window — so plan around the lunch-to-after-work block on weekdays. The shop sits inside a small office-park-style complex on Standiford near Tully Rd, with a shared lot that almost always has parking.

For a Modesto card shop that takes sports and Pokemon cards equally seriously, with real grading services and a Central Valley-leading sealed selection, Teammates is the first stop on most local collectors' lists.