Damaged cards: often yes, at a reduced price reflecting condition — a heavily played but genuine star or vintage card still has a market, while damaged commons are essentially bulk. Fake (counterfeit) cards: reputable shops won't buy known counterfeits, and knowingly selling them is a serious problem, so expect a shop to decline or flag anything inauthentic. If you're unsure whether a card is real, a shop can usually tell you quickly. When buying, that authentication expertise is a big reason to shop in person for expensive cards. Learn how to spot fakes in our authentication FAQs, and find trusted shops in our directory.
Updated Jul 13, 2026