List with us
List your card shop List an event
Home › MLB Baseball Card Shops › New York
MLB Baseball Cards · NY

MLB Baseball Card Shops in New York

Find local MLB baseball card shops in New York — browse hours, ratings, Street View photos, and directions for every listed shop.

33Shops in New York
13Cities Covered
New YorkMost Shops

There are 33 MLB baseball card shops listed in New York, spread across 13 cities including New York, Brooklyn, and Schenectady. New York has the most at 8, though the listings are spread fairly evenly rather than concentrated in one city. 22 of them rate 4.5 or better across at least 20 reviews, led by Dave & Adam's NYC in New York. 10 host in-store events, which is usually the sign of a shop with a regular player base rather than a counter of sealed product. Nationally New York ranks 4th of 48 states for MLB baseball card shops, holding 5% of every one listed.

Top MLB Baseball Card Shops

Highest-rated shops in our directory carrying MLB baseball cards.

View all 33 →
Dave & Adam's NYC storefront
Dave & Adam's NYC
340 reviews
⭐ Top Rated
1350 Broadway, New York, NY
⚾ MLB 🏈 NFL ⚡ Pokémon 🏅 PSA 💎 Singles 🕹️ Vintage 🏆 Events
Hours
11AM–7PM
● Closed
(716) 626-0000 View Shop →
Bleecker Trading storefront
Bleecker Trading
387 reviews
⭐ Top Rated
96 Christopher St, New York, NY
⚾ MLB 🏈 NFL ⚡ Pokémon 🏅 PSA 💎 Singles 🏆 Events 🔮 Magic
Hours
10AM–8PM
● Closed
(646) 430-2136 View Shop →
Great Lakes Sports Cards
42 reviews
★5.0
4161 Transit Rd, Buffalo, NY
⚾ MLB 🏈 NFL 🏀 NBA 🏒 NHL ⚡ Pokémon 🕹️ Vintage
Hours
11AM-6PM
● Closed
716-580-3180 View Shop →
TrueCards of New York
3 reviews
★5.0
101 State St, Schenectady, NY
⚾ MLB 🏈 NFL 🏅 PSA 💎 Singles
Hours
10:30AM-4PM
● Closed
914-306-0285 View Shop →
Breakcity Cards & Memorabilia
159 reviews
★4.9
4408 Milestrip Rd, Buffalo, NY
⚡ Pokémon 🏈 NFL 🏀 NBA ⚾ MLB 💎 Singles
Hours
11AM-8PM
● Closed
716-322-5550 View Shop →
Big Slab Daddy Sport Cards
100 reviews
★4.9
8115 3rd Ave, Brooklyn, NY
⚾ MLB 🏈 NFL 🏅 PSA 💎 Singles 🕹️ Vintage 🔮 Magic 🃏 Yu-Gi-Oh!
Hours
10AM-7PM
● Closed
718-709-0007 View Shop →
Sneakouts
193 reviews
★4.8
2340 Bath Ave, Brooklyn, NY
⚡ Pokémon 💎 Singles ⚾ MLB 🕹️ Vintage 🏆 Events
Hours
11AM-6:30PM
● Closed
718-269-3225 View Shop →
Finnigan's Sportscards
122 reviews
★4.8
1593 Central Ave, Unit 4, Albany, NY
⚾ MLB 🏈 NFL 🏀 NBA 🏒 NHL 💎 Singles 🕹️ Vintage
Hours
10AM-7PM
● Closed
518-218-0578 View Shop →
E and J Boutique storefront
E and J Boutique
120 reviews
★4.7
6906 Fort Hamilton Pkwy, Brooklyn, NY
⚾ MLB 🏈 NFL ⚡ Pokémon 💎 Singles 🏆 Events 🃏 Yu-Gi-Oh!
Hours
11AM–7PM
● Closed
(718) 775-8471 View Shop →
Game On Video Games & Sports Memorabilia
62 reviews
★4.7
2670 Dewey Ave, Rochester, NY
⚾ MLB 🏈 NFL 🏀 NBA 🏅 PSA 🕹️ Vintage
Hours
10AM-7PM
● Closed
585-481-2153 View Shop →
GG Cards & Breaks
57 reviews
★4.7
639 Delmar Pl, Syracuse, NY
⚾ MLB 🏈 NFL 🏀 NBA 🏅 PSA 💎 Singles 🏆 Events 🃏 Yu-Gi-Oh!
Hours
10AM-6PM
● Closed
315-412-0999 View Shop →
CardVault by Tom Brady
38 reviews
★4.7
80 Flatbush Ave, Brooklyn, NY
⚾ MLB 🏈 NFL 🏅 PSA ⚡ Pokémon 💎 Singles 🔮 Magic 🃏 Yu-Gi-Oh!
Hours
11AM-7PM
● Closed
329-218-1462 View Shop →
Upstate CollectibleZ
26 reviews
★4.7
93 W Campbell Rd, Schenectady, NY
⚡ Pokémon 🕹️ Vintage 💎 Singles ⚾ MLB
Hours
9AM-6PM
● Closed
518-212-2138 View Shop →
Collect Binghamton by Piece of The Game
113 reviews
★4.6
174 Clinton St, Binghamton, NY
⚡ Pokémon ⚾ MLB 🏈 NFL 🏅 PSA 💎 Singles 🕹️ Vintage 🔮 Magic 🃏 Yu-Gi-Oh!
Hours
10AM-6PM
● Closed
607-296-6472 View Shop →
Nxt Legaci storefront
Nxt Legaci
95 reviews
★4.6
526 7th Ave, 2nd Floor, New York, NY
⚾ MLB 🏈 NFL ⚡ Pokémon 💎 Singles 🏆 Events 🔮 Magic
Hours
12PM–9PM
● Closed
— View Shop →
Bleecker Trading Upper West Side storefront
Bleecker Trading Upper West Side
78 reviews
★4.6
185 W 80th St, New York, NY
⚾ MLB 🏈 NFL ⚡ Pokémon 🏅 PSA 💎 Singles 🏆 Events 🔮 Magic
Hours
10AM–8PM
● Closed
(929) 745-3001 View Shop →
Collector Cave
384 reviews
★4.5
3021-23 Middletown Rd, Bronx, NY
⚡ Pokémon ⚾ MLB 💎 Singles 🕹️ Vintage 🏅 PSA 🔮 Magic 🃏 Yu-Gi-Oh!
Hours
12PM-7PM
● Closed
718-892-0402 View Shop →
City Cards & Collectibles
94 reviews
★4.5
656 Forest Ave, Staten Island, NY
⚡ Pokémon ⚾ MLB 🏈 NFL 🏀 NBA 🏒 NHL 🏅 PSA
Hours
11AM-8PM
● Closed
347-466-4681 View Shop →
World Champion Trading Cards storefront
World Champion Trading Cards
75 reviews
★4.5
36-07 162nd St, Flushing, NY
⚾ MLB 🏈 NFL ⚡ Pokémon 💎 Singles
Hours
11AM–7PM
● Closed
(347) 368-0104 View Shop →
The Card Barn NYC storefront
The Card Barn NYC
62 reviews
★4.5
499 Oakdale St, Staten Island, NY
⚾ MLB 🏈 NFL ⚡ Pokémon 💎 Singles
Hours
12PM–7PM
● Closed
— View Shop →
Da Shop NY storefront
Da Shop NY
55 reviews
★4.5
6A Elizabeth St, New York, NY
⚾ MLB 🏈 NFL ⚡ Pokémon 🎌 Japanese 💎 Singles
Hours
11AM–7PM
● Closed
(212) 608-9728 View Shop →
The Collector's Cave
40 reviews
★4.5
4011-D Hylan Blvd, Staten Island, NY
🏅 PSA ⚡ Pokémon ⚾ MLB 🏈 NFL 🏆 Events 💎 Singles
Hours
11AM-8PM
● Closed
347-215-2064 View Shop →
Slope Comic & Collectibles
22 reviews
★4.5
151 7th Ave, Brooklyn, NY
⚡ Pokémon 💎 Singles 🕹️ Vintage ⚾ MLB 🔮 Magic
Hours
10AM-6PM
● Closed
646-383-0043 View Shop →
Royal Sports & Entertainment
211 reviews
★4.4
96-11 Metropolitan Ave, Queens, NY
⚾ MLB 🏈 NFL 🕹️ Vintage 🏅 PSA ⚡ Pokémon
Hours
11AM-6PM
● Closed
718-261-5111 View Shop →

MLB Baseball Card Shops by City in New York

Cities with the most shops carrying MLB baseball cards in New York.

New York, NY 8 Brooklyn, NY 6 Schenectady, NY 3 Staten Island, NY 3 Albany, NY 2 Buffalo, NY 2 Rochester, NY 2 Syracuse, NY 2 Binghamton, NY 1 Bronx, NY 1 Flushing, NY 1 Queens, NY 1 Whitestone, NY 1

Questions about MLB baseball card shops in New York

How many MLB baseball card shops are there in New York?
There are 33 listed on The Card Shop Finder, across 13 cities. They average 4.5 stars between them.
Which city in New York has the most MLB baseball card shops?
New York, with 8 listed. After that come Brooklyn with 6 and Schenectady with 3.
Which MLB baseball card shops in New York are rated highest?
Great Lakes Sports Cards in Buffalo currently leads at 5 stars from 42 reviews. Breakcity Cards & Memorabilia in Buffalo is next at 4.9.
Do any MLB baseball card shops in New York host tournaments or in-store events?
10 of the 33 listed do, or 30% of the state. A shop running regular events usually has a standing player base rather than only a counter of sealed product.
Is New York a good state for MLB baseball cards?
It ranks 4th of 48 states for MLB baseball card shops on this site. Florida is the next one up, with 56.

Explore the full card collecting FAQ →

Stay In The Loop

SUBSCRIBE TO OUR
NEWSLETTER

New shop listings, card show dates, hobby news, and exclusive collector insights — delivered to your inbox. No spam, just cardboard.

I collect:

Free forever · Unsubscribe anytime · No spam