List with us
List your card shop List an event
← NEW YORK  ·  CARD SHOP DIRECTORY

CARD SHOPS IN
STATEN ISLAND

Local card shops in Staten Island, New York

3 Shops in Staten Island
4.5★ Avg Rating
196 Total Reviews
0 Upcoming Events

Trading Card Shops in Staten Island

We list 3 trading card shops in Staten Island, serving the local collector community. Shops here cater to Pokémon, MLB baseball, NFL football, with offerings ranging from sealed wax and singles to graded gems, accessories, and tournament-ready supplies.

Local favorites include City Cards & Collectibles (4.5★, 94 reviews). Check back regularly for upcoming card shows and tournaments in the area.

Whether you're chasing the latest releases, cracking packs with friends, or hunting that elusive vintage card, Staten Island's card shops have something for every type of collector. Browse the listings below to find your next favorite spot — and if we've missed a shop you know, tell us and we'll add it.

🗺️ Card Shops Map — Staten Island

Open full map ↗
Jump to: All Cities New York 14 Brooklyn 10 Buffalo 8 Albany 5 Queens 5 Rochester 4 Schenectady 4 Bronx 3 Staten Island 3 Syracuse 3 Binghamton 2 Astoria 1 Corona 1 Flushing 1 Long Island City 1 Whitestone 1 Yonkers 1
All States › New York ›Staten Island
Showing 3 shops in New York · Staten Island · 🏈 NFL Football
🏙️ Staten Island × 🎴 🏈 NFL Football ×
Card shows in New York · 8 upcoming
See the calendar →
Oct 17 The 42nd St Card Show (October) New York Oct 24 The Hofstra Show Hempstead Oct 24 New York Evolving TCG Show (October) Flushing
The Collector's Cave
40 reviews
★ 4.5
4011-D Hylan Blvd, Staten Island, NY
🏅 PSA ⚡ Pokémon ⚾ MLB 🏈 NFL 🏆 Events 💎 Singles
Hours
11AM-8PM
● Closed
Staten Island's only independent authorized PSA dealer pairs graded comics and sports cards with TCG singles, Funko Pops and a Saturday trade night.…
347-215-2064
View Shop →
City Cards & Collectibles
94 reviews
★ 4.5
656 Forest Ave, Staten Island, NY
⚡ Pokémon ⚾ MLB 🏈 NFL 🏀 NBA 🏒 NHL 🏅 PSA
Hours
11AM-8PM
● Closed
Staten Island sports and Pokemon shop on Forest Avenue with case breaks, grading help, autographs and vintage comics, open 11AM-8PM every day.…
347-466-4681
View Shop →
The Card Barn NYC
The Card Barn NYC
62 reviews
★ 4.5
499 Oakdale St, Staten Island, NY
⚾ MLB 🏈 NFL ⚡ Pokémon 💎 Singles
Hours
12PM–7PM
● Closed
Staten Island's go-to card shop for sports cards and Pokémon. Welcoming staff, a strong local following, and the best selection on the island.…
View Shop →

📅 UPCOMING EVENTS IN STATEN ISLAND

Card shows, conventions, and tournaments in and around Staten Island. View all New York events →

📅

No upcoming events in New York right now. Check back soon!

📍 Nearby Cities with Card Shops

The closest other cities with shops in our directory, within 100 miles of Staten Island.

Brooklyn, NY 10 shops · 9.4 mi Newark, NJ 1 shop · 12 mi Jersey City, NJ 4 shops · 12 mi Aberdeen, NJ 1 shop · 12 mi New York, NY 14 shops · 14 mi Summit, NJ 1 shop · 14 mi

📍 Other Cities in New York

Browse card shops in nearby New York cities.

New York 14 shops Brooklyn 10 shops Buffalo 8 shops Albany 5 shops Queens 5 shops Rochester 4 shops Schenectady 4 shops Bronx 3 shops View all New York →

❓ Card Shops in Staten Island — FAQ

How many card shops are in Staten Island, New York?
There are currently 3 trading card shops listed in Staten Island on The Card Shop Finder. Each listing includes hours, reviews, contact info, and directions.
What is the highest-rated card shop in Staten Island?
City Cards & Collectibles currently has the highest rating at 4.5★ across 94 reviews.
What kinds of cards do Staten Island shops specialize in?
The most common specialties in Staten Island are: Pokémon cards (3 shops), MLB baseball cards (3 shops), NFL football cards (3 shops).
Are there card shows or tournaments in Staten Island?
There are no card shows or tournaments scheduled for Staten Island right now. Check back soon — new events are added regularly.

Find Card Shops Across the US

The Card Shop Finder is the national directory for trading card shops. Whether you collect Pokémon, MLB, NFL, or vintage cards, we help you find vetted local shops with hours, reviews, and directions. You're viewing card shops in Staten Island, New York. See every New York shop, or jump to another state below.

AK AL AR AZ CA CO CT DE FL GA HI IA ID IL IN KS KY LA MA MD ME MI MN MO MS MT NC ND NE NH NJ NM NV NY OH OK OR PA RI SC SD TN TX UT VA VT WA WI WV WY