Magic City Sports Cards

Kenmore Boulevard institution since 1993 dealing vintage Topps, 1960s-70s sports cards, and a side of Pokemon and Yu-Gi-Oh in Akron.

Open since 1993, Magic City Sports Cards is a Kenmore Boulevard institution and one of the older card counters in Akron. The draw here is vintage: shoeboxes and cases of baseball, basketball, football, and hockey going back to the 1960s and 1970s, the kind of rare, well-worn stock that newer shops simply don't carry.

The shop is unapologetically old-school. Pull up to the counter and dig — set-builders chasing a specific year and collectors hunting star cards from decades past are the regulars here. Modern sports product and a selection of Pokemon and Yu-Gi-Oh round things out for younger collectors and trade-ins, but vintage sports is the heart of the place.

More than thirty years in one neighborhood has made this a trusted stop for appraisals and selling collections. The owner's long memory for the market means fair, knowledgeable conversations whether you're buying a single or moving a box.

Hours are limited and worth planning around: the shop opens Thursday and Friday afternoons until 6PM and Saturdays 11AM to 5PM, and is closed the rest of the week. For collectors who want a genuine vintage Akron card shop, Magic City is a destination in its own right.