UGA Games

Bethel Road buy-sell-trade stop where Pokemon and Magic singles share counter space with video games, console repair, and quick cash appraisals.

UGA Games treats the transaction as the product. This Bethel Road storefront in northwest Columbus has built its reputation on quick, honest buy-sell-trade service across two categories: trading cards and video games. Walk in with a binder of Pokemon cards or a box of Magic: The Gathering staples and the counter staff will sort, evaluate, and make an offer on the spot — no appointment, no consignment wait.

On the sales floor, glass cases hold graded and raw singles for Pokemon and Magic, with sealed booster packs and boxes shelved behind the register. The video game side spans modern releases back through retro cartridges and consoles, and the shop's in-house console repair service — an uncommon offering for a card-carrying game store — keeps a steady stream of non-collectors walking through the door, some of whom leave with their first booster pack.

The 4.7-star Google rating across more than 400 reviews centers on trust. Customers repeatedly describe offers that matched or beat quotes from bigger stores, and staff who explain their pricing rather than hiding behind a buylist screen. That transparency has made UGA a default recommendation on Columbus collector forums for anyone selling a mid-sized collection without the hassle of listing it piecemeal online.

Hours run 11AM to 8PM Monday through Saturday and noon to 6PM Sunday, and the Bethel Road location sits in a busy retail strip with abundant parking, minutes from Upper Arlington and the OSU campus area. For collectors on the northwest side who want a Columbus card shop that moves at the speed of a pawn counter but prices like a hobby store, UGA Games fills the slot.