Phyrexia: All Will Be One: Booster Box Prices & Sealed Products

Quick facts

Sealed products for Phyrexia: All Will Be One

Draft Booster Box

Thirty-six packs of fifteen cards plus a token or ad card, with roughly one in three packs containing a traditional foil. The set's toxic and poison mechanics made for a distinctive limited format. Boxes run $215-$265.

Set Booster Box

Thirty packs of twelve cards, each with an art card, a token or ad card and a roughly one-in-four chance of a card from The List. Boxes sit at $300-$380, with completed sales near the bottom of that range and retail at the top.

Collector Booster Box

Twelve Collector Boosters of eleven slots each: four foil commons, two foil uncommons, a foil basic land, a foil rare or mythic, an extended-art rare, an extended-art rare or mythic from the Commander or Jumpstart decks, an ichor-treatment common or uncommon and its foil counterpart, a step-and-compleat foil, a Booster Fun rare or mythic and a foil Booster Fun or extended-art card. Step-and-compleat foil appears on 67 cards and only in this product. Boxes trade across a wide $950-$1,400 band, with completed sales near $975, Star City Games at $1,050 and Card Kingdom near $1,400.

Bundle: Compleat Edition

A limited product released March 3, 2023 holding twelve Set Boosters, a Phyrexian-language Phyrexian Arena promo and a Compleat Edition Booster containing ten oil slick raised foil basic lands and two oil slick raised foil mythic rares drawn from a pool of twenty. Oil slick raised foil exists nowhere else. This product has appreciated sharply and now trades at $440-$500.

Bundle and Jumpstart Booster Box

The standard Bundle holds eight Set Boosters, a foil Karumonix promo, forty basic lands, a spindown die and a storage box at roughly $250-$280. The Jumpstart Booster Box is twenty packs of twenty cards across five themes with two variations each, and runs $110-$200 depending on seller.

Commander Decks and Prerelease Kit

Two Commander decks shipped: Corrupting Influence, led by Ixhel, Scion of Atraxa, and Rebellion Rising, led by Neyali, Suns' Vanguard. Each holds a hundred-card deck, a foil-etched display commander and a Collector Booster Sample Pack, and they sell for $45-$90. Prerelease Kits contain six Draft Boosters and a foil year-stamped rare, with roughly one in fifteen holding a special Phyrexian spindown die; they run $80-$105.

Chase cards and Booster Fun treatments

Elesh Norn, Mother of Machines in the compleat frame is the set's best single at roughly $375, with the borderless version near $93. Atraxa, Grand Unifier follows at about $125 non-foil, with the oil slick raised foil version near $96. Mondrak, Glory Dominus sits near $113, and its compleat version near $78.

The treatment list is unusually deep for an in-universe set. Step-and-compleat foil uses a laminate that highlights the Phyrexian symbols on the card and covers 67 cards across all rarities, Collector Booster only. Ichor treatment appears on a short list of commons and uncommons. Oil slick raised foil is limited to the Compleat Edition Bundle and covers twenty mythics plus the basic lands. Beyond those there are borderless planeswalkers, Phyrexian-language printings, extended art and the standard showcase frames.

To be clear about a frequent search: Phyrexia: All Will Be One had no serialized cards in its boosters. The serialized Phyrexian praetors people remember came from a separate Secret Lair release, not from ONE Collector Boosters.

Is Phyrexia: All Will Be One worth buying sealed?

Collector Boosters for this set have run up hard, and that run-up is now the main argument against buying them. At $1,000 or more per box, you are paying roughly $85 a pack for a product whose realistic ceiling is a $375 compleat Elesh Norn. Most boxes will not produce one. Expected value sits well below price, and it is not close.

The more interesting product is the Compleat Edition Bundle. It was a genuinely limited run and oil slick raised foil has never been reprinted in that form. At $440-$500 it is still expensive relative to the cards inside, but the scarcity argument is real in a way the Collector box argument is not.

For everyone else: the Draft box at around $240 is a fine way to play a distinctive limited format, and singles are a far cheaper route to any specific card. Reprint risk is meaningful on Atraxa and Elesh Norn, both Commander staples Wizards has reason to revisit. Treat ONE sealed as a play purchase or a collectible, not a hold.

How to spot fakes, resealed and mapped boxes

The price gap between a sealed ONE Collector box and its opened contents makes this a prime resealing target. Check the shrink for even tension across the top face, machine-cut seams without overlap, and no gloss change or adhesive residue where the wrap folds. A rewrapped box usually feels slightly loose when you press the centre of the lid.

Loose Collector Boosters are risky because a step-and-compleat card has a different laminate thickness, which makes weighing viable. Buy Collector Boosters from a shop that opens the box in front of you or not at all. For the Compleat Edition Bundle, confirm the inner Compleat Edition Booster is still sealed inside the box, since the oil slick booster is the only part with real value and is the obvious thing for a bad seller to remove.

Where to buy Phyrexia: All Will Be One sealed

Local shops occasionally still have ONE Draft and Set boxes at old shelf prices, which is a meaningful discount to current online levels. Start with the card shop directory, and check card shows for Commander decks, Jumpstart boxes and the Compleat Edition Bundle. Online, these searches work:

• MTG Phyrexia All Will Be One Collector Booster Box sealed
• Phyrexia All Will Be One Compleat Edition Bundle sealed
• Phyrexia All Will Be One Draft Booster Box factory sealed