Replay Sports Cards

Replay Sports Cards in Aurora, Colorado at Stanley Marketplace offers sealed boxes, graded slabs, singles, and full-service buying, selling, trading & grading.

Replay Sports Cards opened its first Colorado location in December 2025 at Aurora's iconic Stanley Marketplace, bringing a modern, collector-first card shop experience to the Denver metro area. As America's first national sports card shop franchise, Replay combines the welcoming atmosphere of a traditional local card shop with premium services including buying, selling, trading, and grading for collectors of all ages and experience levels.

The shop offers an expansive selection of sealed sports trading card boxes, singles, and graded slabs spanning current releases and vintage cards, with exclusive rare and autographed pieces for serious collectors. From hobby boxes and blaster packs to PSA-graded rookies and high-end singles, Replay's inventory caters to everyone from kids opening their first packs to seasoned investors. The shop features $1 and $5 bargain bins alongside premium showcase cards, ensuring options at every price point for MLB, NFL, NBA, and NHL collectors.

Replay Sports Cards provides comprehensive services beyond retail, including professional card grading submissions, collection buying, and trade-in options with fair and transparent evaluations. The shop hosts in-store events, trade nights, and community initiatives through its Replay Gives Back program. Collectors can also engage with the shop online through live breaks and auctions streaming 102 hours weekly on TikTok and Whatnot, connecting the local and national collector communities.

Located on the second floor of Stanley Marketplace alongside 50+ shops and restaurants, Replay Sports Cards offers extended hours Thursday through Saturday and a comfortable, modern environment perfect for browsing, trading, and celebrating the hobby. Whether you're a Denver card shop regular or new to collecting, Replay delivers the expertise, selection, and community atmosphere that make it a must-visit Aurora card shop destination.