Card shows in Overland Park
· 3 upcoming
See the calendar →
Johnson County Collecting
Overland Park is the Kansas side of the Kansas City hobby scene, and the four shops we list there cover a genuinely wide span — from a store that opened recently to one that has been running since 1988.
The Baseball Card Store on West 87th Street, in the Library Shops stretch, is the elder statesman: one of the longest-running card shops in the entire Kansas City metro, a PSA dealer, stocking vintage stars from the 1800s onward alongside fresh wax. Two shops sit on Metcalf Avenue at opposite ends. Victory Road Collections at the north end runs sanctioned Pokémon League and Magic events with a kid-friendly play space. Down on the busier southern stretch, Nerdstalgia was opened by childhood friends Greg Henry and Chris Johnson and leans nostalgic.
All Star Cards on Antioch Road is family-owned, covering baseball, basketball, football and hockey with an active buying list for collections. Overland Park also has one of the better event calendars in the region.
The highest-rated card shops in Overland Park, hand-picked by collector reviews.
Card shows, conventions, and tournaments in and around Overland Park. View all Kansas events →
The Baseball Card Store at 9637 West 87th Street has been serving Kansas City collectors since 1988 — one of the longest-running card shops in the entire metro, on either side of the state line.
It sits in the Library Shops stretch of 87th Street and stocks vintage stars from the 1800s onward alongside fresh wax and set-filler commons. Pre-war and 19th-century material is genuinely unusual to find on a shelf rather than in an auction, and it is the kind of inventory that only exists where a shop has been buying local collections for nearly forty years.
It is also a PSA dealer, which makes it the practical answer to grading in Overland Park. Open Tuesday through Saturday, closed Sunday and Monday.
Metcalf Avenue runs the length of Overland Park and holds two shops that could not be more different, roughly six miles apart.
Victory Road Collections at 8715 Metcalf, at the northern end, is built for play — a sanctioned Pokémon League, weekly Magic events, and a kid-friendly play space designed for everyone from first-time Pokémon players to Commander veterans. Parking is straightforward in the Metcalf strip lot, which matters more than it sounds when you are bringing children to a league night. Hours run late twice a week, on Wednesday and Friday — the two nights events fire. Closed Tuesday.
Nerdstalgia Collectibles and Comics at 14878 Metcalf, on the busier southern stretch, was opened by childhood friends Greg Henry and Chris Johnson and leans exactly where the name suggests — Pokémon and comics alongside vintage toys, movie posters, Funkos and video-game memorabilia. Open Wednesday through Sunday, closed Monday and Tuesday.
Overland Park runs three events on the calendar — more than most four-shop markets — and they cover two very different scales.
TableTop Game & Hobby hosts recurring Pokémon TCG League Cups, in August and September. League Cups sit above weekly league play in the Play! Pokémon structure and award Championship Points toward Worlds invitations, so they draw players from across the metro rather than just the neighbourhood. (Note TableTop is an event venue here rather than a shop listed in this directory.)
At the other end, the All American Collectors Expo takes over the Overland Park Convention Center in November across three days — a genuine show floor with the dealer depth that no amount of shop-hopping replicates.
If you are selling, that November weekend is the date to plan around. See selling at card shows and first card show prep.
All Star Cards at 15074 Antioch Road in south Overland Park is family-owned, covering vintage and modern baseball, basketball, football and hockey, with an active buying list for collections.
Its schedule is genuinely unusual for a card shop: weekdays only, closed Saturday and Sunday. Almost every card shop lives on weekend traffic; a weekday-only shop is running a different business — likely weighted toward buying, dealing and consignment rather than walk-in retail.
Practically that means two things. You cannot visit at the weekend, so plan accordingly. And if you are selling a collection, a shop structured around buying is often a better conversation than one structured around retail. Our selling guide covers pricing before you go.
Overland Park is the Kansas side of a metro that straddles the state line, and treating it in isolation misses the point — Kansas City hobby life runs across both.
Within Kansas, Wichita is the deepest listing, with Topeka and Olathe next. Olathe is close enough to fold into an Overland Park trip; Topeka is about an hour west and worth a day of its own, with a pair of shops a few blocks apart on SW Gage Boulevard.
What Overland Park gives you locally is unusual range for four shops: a 1988 vintage dealer and PSA outlet, a modern play-focused Pokémon store, a nostalgia crossover shop, and a weekday buying operation. That is four genuinely different reasons to visit, which is better than four of the same. Browse every card shop in Kansas.
The closest other cities with shops in our directory, within 100 miles of Overland Park.
Browse card shops in nearby Kansas cities.