All Star Cards

A family-owned Antioch Road dealer specializing in vintage and modern baseball, basketball, football, and hockey, with an active buying list for collections.

All Star Cards is the kind of focused, family-owned operation that sports collectors hunt for. Set up on Antioch Road in south Overland Park, the shop deals squarely in cards, no board games or comics filling the shelves, just deep inventory across baseball, basketball, football, and hockey from the vintage era through today's releases.

The family running it has built a reputation as serious buyers and sellers, and they maintain an active buying list, which makes this a logical first call if you've inherited a collection or are looking to move star cards and complete sets. They handle both raw vintage and modern product, and as longtime hobby dealers they price with the kind of market knowledge that comes from decades in the business.

The atmosphere is transactional in the best way: come in knowing what you want or what you're selling, and you'll get a straight, fair conversation. It's less a hangout than a true sports cards Overland Park dealer, which is exactly the appeal for collectors who'd rather talk grades and comps than browse sealed Pokemon.

Worth noting on timing: the shop keeps weekday business hours, open Monday through Thursday 9 to 6 and Friday 9 to 5, and is closed both Saturday and Sunday. That weekday-only schedule is unusual for a card shop, so plan a lunch-break or afternoon visit rather than a weekend trip. Parking is straightforward at the Antioch Road location.