Top MLB Baseball Cards Shops
Highest-rated shops in our directory carrying mlb baseball cards.
Indy Card Exchange
195 reviews
⭐ Top Rated
7035 E 96th St, Ste P, Indianapolis, IN
Hours
Tue–Thu 11AM–6PM · Fri 11AM–6PM · Sat 11AM–5PM · Sun 12–5PM · Mon Closed
Best Card Shop
64 reviews
2030 Stafford Rd, Plainfield, IN
Hours
Tue–Fri 12–7PM · Sat 10AM–6PM · Sun 12–5PM · Mon Closed
Fan Cave Indy
134 reviews
4805 Madison Ave, Indianapolis, IN
Hours
Tue–Fri 12–7PM · Sat 10AM–6PM · Sun 12–5PM · Mon Closed
The Card Depot
24 reviews
7038 Madison Ave, Indianapolis, IN
Hours
Mon-Fri 11a-6p, Sat 10a-5p
Vintage Indy Sports
108 reviews
1450 Main St, Ste B, Indianapolis, IN
Hours
Wed–Sat 11AM–6PM · Sun 12–5PM · Mon–Tue Closed
Summit Sports, Comics & Games
60 reviews
4240 W Jefferson Blvd Ste M-8, Fort Wayne, IN
Hours
K & L Cards
96 reviews
3100 Meridian Parke Dr, Ste Z, Greenwood, IN
Hours
Mon–Fri 11AM–6PM · Sat 10AM–5PM · Sun 12–4PM
Collector's Den
72 reviews
6214 Carrollton Ave, Indianapolis, IN
Hours
Tue–Sat 11AM–7PM · Sun 12–5PM · Mon Closed
Sport Spot
30 reviews
1015 E Coliseum Blvd, Fort Wayne, IN
Hours
The Dugout
182 reviews
5707 W Morris St, Indianapolis, IN
Hours
Mon–Thu 12–7PM · Fri 12PM–12AM · Sat 11AM–6PM · Sun 12–5PM