List with us
List your card shop List an event
Is this your shop? Claim it free and add a photo →
New York, NY · Card Shop

Montasy Comics NYC

431 5th Avenue, Floor 2, New York, NY 10016
4.1
★★★★★
870 reviews on Google
🏪
Is this your business?
Claim it free to keep your hours, phone, address and description accurate and add your main photo. Premium adds a Featured spot, a photo gallery and more.
Claim This Listing →

About The Shop

Montasy Comics NYC in Midtown Manhattan, New York offers sports cards, Pokémon, Magic, Yu-Gi-Oh, comics, and weekly TCG tournaments near Bryant Park.

Montasy Comics NYC has been a vibrant hub for trading card games, sports cards, and comic books in Midtown Manhattan for over a decade, growing from a small dream into one of New York City's most comprehensive hobby destinations. Located on the second floor at 431 5th Avenue near Bryant Park and Grand Central Terminal, this spacious store brings together comics, TCGs, and sports cards in one epic universe just blocks from some of NYC's most iconic landmarks.

The shop carries an extensive selection of sports cards from Topps, Panini, and Upper Deck covering baseball, basketball, football, hockey, soccer, and UFC alongside a massive inventory of trading card games including Pokémon, Magic: The Gathering, Yu-Gi-Oh!, One Piece, Dragon Ball, Digimon, and My Hero Academia. Collectors can find both sealed booster boxes and packs plus organized singles binders with competitive pricing that aims to match TCGplayer rates. The store also stocks Funko Pops, collectible toys, graphic novels, and a full selection of card supplies from Ultra Pro to protect your collection.

Montasy Comics NYC is recognized throughout the New York City card shop scene for hosting frequent TCG tournaments including Friday Night Magic, Pokémon league events, and other organized play that fosters a strong sense of community among gamers and collectors. The third floor features special boxes, premium singles, memorabilia, and dedicated event space where fans gather to celebrate shared passions. Whether you're a seasoned collector hunting rare vintage cards or a casual enthusiast picking up the latest Marvel comic, the store's minimalist layout and central location make it easily accessible via multiple subway lines.

With daily hours from 11 AM to 8 PM and a commitment to serving collectors, gamers, and comic readers under one roof, Montasy Comics NYC continues to thrive as a cornerstone of the Manhattan hobby community where fandom lives in every form, on every shelf, and in every story shared.

What They Carry

🏆
Sports Cards
⚡
Pokemon Cards
🪄
Magic the Gathering
🐉
Yu-Gi-Oh
🃏
One Piece
🃏
Dragon Ball
📚
Comic Books
🃏
Funko Pops
🧰
Card Supplies

Services

TCG Tournaments Friday Night Magic Buy/Sell/Trade
Status
● Closed Mon–Thu 11AM-7PM · Fri 11AM-8PM · Sat–Sun 11AM-7PM
Weekly Hours
Monday 11AM-7PM
Tuesday 11AM-7PM
Wednesday 11AM-7PM
Thursday 11AM-7PM
Friday 11AM-8PM
Saturday 11AM-7PM
Sunday 11AM-7PM
📍 Get Directions 📞 Call Now
🗺️
431 5th Avenue, Floor 2
New York, NY
Sponsored
Get 20% off your first purchase at Arena Club with code CARDSHOPFINDER
Sponsored
Cardstock: scan and organize your sports cards — install the app on the App Store
📬 Newsletter

GET COLLECTOR UPDATES

New shop listings, card show dates, and hobby news — straight to your inbox.

Free · No spam · Unsubscribe anytime

RECENTLY VIEWED