S & S Sports Card

Open since the late 1990s, this W Washington St shop is Broken Arrow's old-guard sports card counter — vintage baseball, football singles and sealed wax.

Steve Burris opened S & S Sports Card on West Washington Street in the late 1990s, which makes it one of the longest-running card shops in the Tulsa metro. There is no TCG side business here and no video games — this is a sports card store, full stop, and the inventory reflects almost three decades of accumulation.

The counter cases carry modern rookies and graded cards, while the deeper value sits in the vintage stock: Topps baseball going back decades, football and basketball singles, and boxes that reward a collector who knows what they are hunting. Sealed hobby boxes and packs are stocked across the major sports releases, which is why local breakers keep the shop on their rotation. With 179 Google reviews the feedback is genuinely mixed — pricing and staff interactions draw both praise and complaints — so it is worth going in knowing what a card is worth to you before you negotiate.

Hours are the biggest planning constraint. This is a daytime business: Monday through Friday 9:30AM to 5:30PM, Saturday closing early at 4PM, and closed all day Sunday. If you work a standard schedule, Saturday morning is realistically your only window, and it is also the busiest stretch of the week.

The store sits on a commercial stretch of West Washington with its own parking, a few minutes from the Broken Arrow Expressway. Layout is straightforward — cases along the front, boxes and supplies behind — and the whole floor is browsable in one pass.

For anyone building a vintage sports run in the Tulsa area, this is a required stop simply because of how long the inventory has been accumulating. Bring cash, know your comps, and give yourself time before the 5:30 close.