Collect 'Em Again

Graded baseball cards, vintage Pokemon, and walls of comics fill this downtown Waco shop, with an open community Trade Day one Sunday every month.

The rooster head worked into the C of the logo tells you this is more than a storefront. Collect 'Em Again opened in September 2025 at 930 Austin Avenue as the second act of Collect 'Em Cards, the downtown shop that went dark after co-owner "Rooster" passed away unexpectedly. Original owner Kevin Ferguson, the sports card and memorabilia half of the operation, teamed up with toy and comics specialist Benjamin Woody to bring the collection back to Austin Avenue, next door to the Performing Arts Community Center.

The inventory runs from quarter-bin finds to showcase pieces worth several thousand dollars. Graded baseball cards and autographed balls and bats anchor the sports side, vintage Pokemon shares shelf space with modern sets, and the comic selection stretches from silver-age keys to current releases; the crown jewel is a CGC-graded Fantastic Four #48, the first appearance of the Silver Surfer. Retro arcade machines, 90s X-Men figures, Starting Lineups, records, and movie posters round out the browsing.

Community is the point here. Baylor law students wander in to decompress, Baylor baseball players dig through the card cases, and one Sunday a month the shop hosts Trade Day from noon to 3PM, an open-floor session where collectors swap directly with each other. The owners are also launching the Collect 'Em on the Brazos Card Show at the Waco Convention Center, with roughly 100 vendor tables planned.

Anyone searching for a Waco card shop that treats sports wax and Pokemon cards with equal seriousness should start on Austin Avenue. The shop is closed Mondays; weekdays and Saturdays run 10AM to 7PM, and Sunday afternoons from noon to 5PM line up nicely with Trade Day weekends.