Card Shops in Madison, Wisconsin — 2 Local Pokémon, MLB & NFL Trading Card Stores

Trading Card Shops in Madison

Madison is home to 2 trading card shops serving the local collector community. Shops here cater to singles, tournaments and events, MLB baseball, with offerings ranging from sealed wax and singles to graded gems, accessories, and tournament-ready supplies.

Local favorites include Rabbit Hole Sports Cards (4.8★, 131 reviews). Check back regularly for upcoming card shows and tournaments in the area.

Whether you're chasing the latest releases, cracking packs with friends, or hunting that elusive vintage card, Madison's card shops have something for every type of collector. Browse the listings below to find your next favorite spot.

Showing 2 shops in Wisconsin · Madison · 🏆 Events / Tournaments

🏙️ Madison × 🎴 🏆 Events / Tournaments ×

Rabbit Hole Sports Cards

131 reviews

★ 4.8

302 E Towne Way Unit B-119, Madison, WI

⚾ MLB 🏈 NFL 🏀 NBA 🏒 NHL 💎 Singles 🏆 Events

Hours

Tue–Sat 10AM–8PM · Sun 11AM–5PM · Mon Closed

● Closed

Rabbit Hole Sports Cards is a newer Madison standout that has quickly built a devoted following for its sports card selection, autograph events, and welcoming v…

6640 Odana Rd, Madison, WI

⚡ Pokémon 💎 Singles 🏆 Events

Hours

Mon 12–10PM · Tue 12–10PM · Wed 12–8PM · Thu 12–10PM · Fri 12–10PM · Sat 10AM–8PM · Sun 12–8PM

● Open

Pegasus Games has been serving Madison and the surrounding area for over 45 years, making it one of Wisconsin\'s most storied hobby shops. A beloved community h…

(608) 833-4263

View Shop →

❓ Card Shops in Madison — FAQ

How many card shops are in Madison, Wisconsin?

There are currently 2 trading card shops listed in Madison on The Card Shop Finder. Each listing includes hours, reviews, contact info, and directions.

What is the highest-rated card shop in Madison?

Rabbit Hole Sports Cards currently has the highest rating at 4.8★ across 131 reviews.

What kinds of cards do Madison shops specialize in?

The most common specialties in Madison are: singles (2 shops), tournaments and events (2 shops), MLB baseball cards (1 shop).

Are there card shows or tournaments in Madison?

There are no card shows or tournaments scheduled for Madison right now. Check back soon — new events are added regularly.

CARD SHOPS IN
MADISON

Trading Card Shops in Madison

⭐ Top Picks in Madison

🗺️ Card Shops Map — Madison

📅 UPCOMING EVENTS IN MADISON

📍 Other Cities in Wisconsin

❓ Card Shops in Madison — FAQ

Find Card Shops Across the US

CARD SHOPS INMADISON

Trading Card Shops in Madison

⭐ Top Picks in Madison

🗺️ Card Shops Map — Madison

📅 UPCOMING EVENTS IN MADISON

📍 Other Cities in Wisconsin

❓ Card Shops in Madison — FAQ

Find Card Shops Across the US

CARD SHOPS IN
MADISON