Bulletproof Comics Inc

Three decades near Brooklyn College, this Nostrand Avenue institution stocks Magic at unbeatable prices alongside Pokemon, comics and a wall of figures.

Few Brooklyn shops of any kind have been in continuous operation since 1992. Bulletproof Comics has managed it on Nostrand Avenue near Brooklyn College, accumulating 564 Google reviews and a 4.7 average along the way — numbers that put it among the most reviewed hobby retailers in the borough.

Magic: The Gathering is where the store's reputation is sharpest. Customers describe the pricing as unbeatable, and for players in Flatbush and Midwood this has long been the default place to buy rather than order online. Pokemon and Yu-Gi-Oh both hold real inventory as well, and the trading card section is substantial enough that people travel to it specifically.

The rest of the store is packed in the best sense. Comics and manga run deep, long boxes crowd the aisles, and video games, action figures and t-shirts fill whatever space remains. The density is part of the appeal; several reviewers note that the range of stock is genuinely fantastic even if navigating it takes patience. Somewhat unexpectedly, the shop also runs a smoothie bar, which regulars treat as one of its defining quirks.

Thirty-four years in one location produces a particular kind of staff knowledge, and it shows in how quickly someone can point you to a specific issue or set. The store handles buying, selling and trading across comics and cards, and curbside pickup remains available for customers who prefer it.

Hours run long: 11AM to 9PM Monday through Friday, 11AM to 8PM Saturday and 11AM to 6PM Sunday. That late weekday close makes it one of the few Brooklyn card shop options genuinely reachable after a full work day. The 2 and 5 trains at Flatbush Avenue-Brooklyn College put it within a short walk, and the surrounding stretch of Nostrand has ample foot traffic well into the evening.