AJ Sports Collectables

Kenosha's vintage sports card destination — pre-1980 Topps, T206-era tobacco cards, and graded slabs alongside Pokemon and modern wax.

Few shops in southeastern Wisconsin go as deep on vintage as AJ Sports Collectables. The 75th Street store bills itself as the Midwest's premiere stop for new and vintage sports cards, and the cases back it up: pre-1980 baseball, T206-era tobacco cards, and graded holders share space with current-year rookies, prospects, and sealed wax. For collectors chasing old cardboard, this Kenosha card shop is the area's first call.

The sports side is only half the story. AJ's also stocks Pokemon cards, Magic: The Gathering, and Yu-Gi-Oh!, plus a memorabilia wall of jerseys, bobbleheads, autographs, and even coins and stamps — a reflection of the ownership's 30-plus years in the collectibles trade. It makes the store an easy stop whether you're hunting a slabbed Hank Aaron or a booster box for the kids.

Customers consistently describe a clean, well-organized floor packed tight with cards, sets, and memorabilia, and staffers Sam and Nick draw regular praise by name for walking collectors through buys, sells, and appraisals without pressure. That service reputation shows in the numbers: 4.7 stars across 159 Google reviews, among the best-rated card stores in Kenosha.

Hours favor daytime collectors — 10AM to 6PM Monday through Friday and 10AM to 4PM on both Saturday and Sunday — so weekend mornings are the window for unhurried case time. The shop sits in a strip at 4623 75th St Unit 11 on Kenosha's west retail corridor with parking at the door. If you're selling, bring the whole collection; the store buys everything from raw singles to estate lots and handles trading cards in Kenosha at every price point.