Comic Paradise Plus 2
87 reviews
183 Holland Avenue, Morgantown, WV
Hours
Closed today
Holland Avenue's second Comic Paradise location stocks Magic singles among the back issues and pins — and keeps shop cats who accept head pats as payment.…
Cheryl's Comics & Toys
46 reviews
5216 1/2 MacCorkle Avenue SE, Charleston, WV
Hours
Closed today
Cheryl's Comics & Toys has stocked sport and non-sport trading cards on MacCorkle Avenue in Charleston for more than 37 years running strong.…
Cartridges Galore Video Games
230 reviews
40 High St, Morgantown, WV
Hours
11AM-7PM
High Street's retro game counter doubles as a Pokemon buy/sell/trade stop — walk in for an N64 cart, walk out with singles and a booster box.…
Who's On First?
24 reviews
801 1st St, Huntington, WV
Hours
11AM-6PM
Gary and Buck's vintage-leaning sports shop on 1st Street — Reds memorabilia, graded slabs and boxes of baseball singles priced by conversation, not by algori…
Gameday Sportscards
11 reviews
404 Boyers Ave, Morgantown, WV
Hours
Closed today
A Boyers Avenue sports-only counter open a three-day, three-and-a-half-hour window — modern wax, vintage and buy/sell for Morgantown collectors who plan ahead…
Comic World
55 reviews
1204 4th Avenue, Huntington, WV
Hours
11AM-5PM
Kathleen's 4th Avenue shop has been running since the 1980s — deep comic back issues plus trading cards, on a short Tuesday-through-Saturday schedule.…
Freeman's Sports Cards & Collectibles
6 reviews
721 3rd Ave, Huntington, WV
Hours
12PM-6PM
Third Avenue buyer's shop where Huntington collectors bring sports card lots, toy collections and old video games to move — weekday-only, noon to six.…