Comic Paradise Plus 2

Holland Avenue's second Comic Paradise location stocks Magic singles among the back issues and pins — and keeps shop cats who accept head pats as payment.

The Morgantown branch of Comic Paradise Plus sits on Holland Avenue, off the main drag, and rewards people who make the small detour. The core business is comics — new releases, back issues, trade paperbacks — with Magic: The Gathering cards, pins, and an accumulated layer of collectible oddities filling out the shelves. It carries a 4.8-star average across 87 Google reviews, which is the highest tier for any trading card shop in Morgantown.

What regulars describe is a browse-first store. The stock is the kind that rewards digging: a reviewer this past summer turned up a Crow pin packaged with a VHS cutout, which is a fair snapshot of the inventory's range. Magic singles and sealed product are stocked steadily rather than exhaustively, so this is a stop for filling gaps and finding the unexpected rather than for buying a case of the newest set.

The hours are the tightest of any shop in this guide and need real planning: closed Monday and Tuesday entirely, open Wednesday through Friday from noon to 6PM, and Saturday noon to 4PM only. Sunday is closed. A midweek afternoon is the reliable window.

The shop also has cats, and reviewers mention them almost as often as the merchandise — friendly, free head pats, no purchase necessary. It is a small thing that tells you the operating temperature of the place: slow, personal, unhurried, the opposite of a mall counter.

For Morgantown collectors, the practical case is proximity and price. Holland Avenue is a short hop from downtown, parking is easier than on High Street, and the card prices track fairly. Call 304-291-9576 if you are after something specific before you build a trip around it — a shop this size sells through singles quickly, and the staff will tell you straight whether it is worth coming in.