Hometown Hobbies

Small 4th Avenue storefront that punches above its size on Magic singles and supplies, and stays open past 10 on Fridays for Commander night.

Square footage is the first thing people mention about Hometown Hobbies, and the second thing they mention is how little it matters. The 4th Avenue shop is compact, but the Magic: The Gathering inventory — singles, sealed, precons, and a genuinely deep bench of storage and protection supplies — holds up against stores several times its size. If you need a specific commander piece or a stack of deck boxes in Huntington, this is the first call.

Friday is the day. Where the rest of the week runs a short 1PM to 5PM shift, Friday stretches to 11PM for Magic night, and Commander is the format the regulars have settled on. There is an entry fee, and reviewers are blunt that the prize support more than covers it. Prerelease weekends also run out of this room, which makes a shop this small one of the few actual organized-play addresses in the city.

Dungeons & Dragons is the other half of the identity — rulebooks, dice, accessories — and the staff's willingness to answer rules questions across games comes up repeatedly in reviews. Pokemon and other TCG product is stocked, though in smaller depth than the Magic wall; treat it as a bonus rather than the reason for the trip.

Practical notes for a visit: the weekday window is genuinely short, so do not drive in at 5:30 expecting to browse. Park on 4th Avenue or in one of the nearby lots, and if you are coming specifically for a card, call first — a small store restocks fast but also sells out fast. The shop's own review history notes that evening hours shift around events, so Friday timing is worth confirming.

At 4.3 stars over 62 Google reviews, the picture is a local game store that trades polish for selection and community. As one longtime customer put it, give it a try before defaulting to a big-box store with a fraction of the range. For a Huntington card shop focused on play rather than display cases, this is the one.