Four Horsemen Comics and Gaming

Seven thousand square feet inside Morgantown Mall, split between retail and a back-room gaming floor that runs Magic, Pokemon, Lorcana and One Piece all week.

Four Horsemen has been operating since 2010 and moved into roughly 7,000 square feet at the Morgantown Mall, and the layout is the whole argument for the place: retail up front, a genuinely large gaming space in the back. Reviewers who have followed the shop through the move keep saying the same thing — the new room finally gave the TCG tables and the D&D groups somewhere to breathe.

As a Wizards Play Network store, Magic: The Gathering drives the event calendar, but the schedule is broader than that. Pokemon, Disney Lorcana and One Piece all have regular seatings, and the One Piece Sundays in particular come up in customer reviews as a thing people plan their week around. Buy, sell and trade runs across all of it, so if you are clearing out a bulk box or chasing a single, the counter handles both directions.

Inventory reaches past cards. Comics and new releases, role-playing books and accessories, board games, and collectibles fill the front of the store, which makes this the rare Morgantown card shop you can send a non-collector into without them getting bored in four minutes. The staff reputation is the other consistent thread in reviews: knowledgeable, present, and willing to talk through what is worth buying rather than just ringing it up.

Hours run 11AM to 8PM Monday through Saturday, with a shorter Sunday, and the mall location means parking is not a consideration — there is more of it than the store will ever need. Check the shop's event calendar before you go if you are coming for organized play, since draft and league seatings fill.

At 4.5 stars across roughly 600 Google reviews, it is comfortably the most-reviewed trading cards Morgantown destination, and the reason reviewers reach for phrases like 'nowhere within 50 miles comes close.' If you are making one stop in Monongalia County, make it this one.