List Your Event
Home › MLB Baseball Card Shops › Wisconsin
MLB Baseball Cards · WI

MLB Baseball Cards Card Shops in Wisconsin

Find local mlb baseball cards card shops in Wisconsin — browse hours, ratings, Street View photos, and directions for every listed shop.

14Shops in Wisconsin
10Cities Covered
MilwaukeeMost Shops

There are 14 MLB Baseball Cards card shops listed in Wisconsin, spread across 10 cities including Milwaukee, Madison, and Appleton. Highest-rated currently: Black Gold Sports Cards in Pewaukee.

Baseball cards built the modern hobby, and they remain the deepest specialty category in most card shops. The MLB-focused shops listed below stock current Topps and Bowman product, vintage stars from the 50s through the 80s, and modern rookies — plus the supplies and showcase cases that serious sets demand.

Top MLB Baseball Cards Shops

Highest-rated shops in our directory carrying mlb baseball cards.

View all 14 →
Black Gold Sports Cards storefront
Black Gold Sports Cards
214 reviews
⭐ Top Rated
2327 Silvernail Rd, Pewaukee, WI
⚾ MLB 🏈 NFL 🏀 NBA ⚡ Pokémon 💎 Singles 🕹️ Vintage 🏆 Events
Hours
12PM–5PM
● Closed
(262) 316-0484 View Shop →
CB Hobby storefront
CB Hobby
187 reviews
⭐ Top Rated
200 E 2nd Street Suite C, Kaukauna, WI
⚾ MLB 🏈 NFL 🏀 NBA 🏒 NHL ⚡ Pokémon 💎 Singles 🏆 Events
Hours
12PM–4PM
● Closed
(920) 462-4178 View Shop →
Card & Coin storefront
Card & Coin
163 reviews
⭐ Top Rated
2208 S Ridge Rd Suite 102, Green Bay, WI
⚾ MLB 🏈 NFL 🏀 NBA 🏒 NHL 💎 Singles 🕹️ Vintage
Hours
Closed today
● Closed
(920) 498-0050 View Shop →
Slab Factory - Sports & Trading Cards
275 reviews
★4.9
739 N High Point Rd, Madison, WI
⚾ MLB 🏈 NFL 🏀 NBA 🏅 PSA ⚡ Pokémon 💎 Singles
Hours
11AM-6PM
● Closed
608-620-8304 View Shop →
Mitch's Sports Cards & Collectibles storefront
Mitch's Sports Cards & Collectibles
142 reviews
★4.8
11235 N Cedarburg Rd, Mequon, WI
⚾ MLB 🏈 NFL 🏀 NBA ⚡ Pokémon 💎 Singles 🏆 Events
Hours
11AM–4PM
● Closed
(262) 302-4209 View Shop →
Rabbit Hole Sports Cards storefront
Rabbit Hole Sports Cards
131 reviews
★4.8
302 E Towne Way Unit B-119, Madison, WI
⚾ MLB 🏈 NFL 🏀 NBA 🏒 NHL 💎 Singles 🏆 Events
Hours
11AM–5PM
● Closed
(608) 285-9614 View Shop →
Name That Card storefront
Name That Card
56 reviews
★4.8
9209 W Bluemound Rd Ste 3, Milwaukee, WI
⚾ MLB 🏈 NFL 🏀 NBA 🕹️ Vintage 🏅 PSA 💎 Singles
Hours
Closed today
● Closed
414-258-0978 View Shop →
Nexgen Cards storefront
Nexgen Cards
42 reviews
★4.8
1432 E Brady St, Milwaukee, WI
⚡ Pokémon ⚾ MLB 🏈 NFL 🏀 NBA 💎 Singles 🏅 PSA
Hours
10AM-6PM
● Closed
414-249-3060 View Shop →
AJ Sports Collectables
159 reviews
★4.7
4623 75th St Unit 11, Kenosha, WI
⚾ MLB 🏈 NFL 🕹️ Vintage 🏅 PSA ⚡ Pokémon 💎 Singles
Hours
10AM-4PM
● Closed
800-781-2030 View Shop →
Ultimate Authentics storefront
Ultimate Authentics
118 reviews
★4.7
1621 Westgate Rd Suite 3, Eau Claire, WI
⚾ MLB 🏈 NFL 🏀 NBA ⚡ Pokémon 💎 Singles 🕹️ Vintage
Hours
10AM–7PM
● Closed
(715) 839-7503 View Shop →
Fox Cities Cards storefront
Fox Cities Cards
74 reviews
★4.6
1881 N Casaloma Dr, Appleton, WI
⚾ MLB 🏈 NFL 🏀 NBA ⚡ Pokémon 💎 Singles
Hours
Closed today
● Closed
(920) 532-3139 View Shop →
Diamond Sports Cards storefront
Diamond Sports Cards
38 reviews
★4.6
4235 S Howell Ave, Milwaukee, WI
⚾ MLB 🏈 NFL 🏀 NBA 🕹️ Vintage 🏅 PSA 💎 Singles
Hours
Closed today
● Closed
414-483-2273 View Shop →
Waukesha Sportscards storefront
Waukesha Sportscards
97 reviews
★4.5
2120 E Moreland Blvd Unit O-5, Waukesha, WI
⚾ MLB 🏈 NFL 🏀 NBA 🏒 NHL 💎 Singles 🕹️ Vintage
Hours
Closed today
● Closed
(262) 544-0959 View Shop →
All American Sports storefront
All American Sports
31 reviews
★4.5
4034 W National Ave, Milwaukee, WI
⚾ MLB 🏈 NFL 🏀 NBA 🕹️ Vintage 🏅 PSA 💎 Singles
Hours
Closed today
● Closed
414-672-7777 View Shop →

MLB Baseball Cards Card Shops by City in Wisconsin

Cities with the most shops carrying mlb baseball cards in Wisconsin.

Milwaukee, WI 4 Madison, WI 2 Appleton, WI 1 Eau Claire, WI 1 Green Bay, WI 1 Kaukauna, WI 1 Kenosha, WI 1 Mequon, WI 1 Pewaukee, WI 1 Waukesha, WI 1

Frequently Asked Questions

What kinds of baseball cards do these shops carry?
Most carry the full range — current-year Topps and Bowman, modern rookies, vintage stars, graded slabs, supplies, and often sealed product for case breaks.
Do baseball card shops sell graded cards?
Yes — most shops with showcase cases stock graded singles from PSA, BGS, SGC, and CSG. The shops tagged with "PSA" specifically may also accept grading submissions on your behalf.
When is the best time to visit for fresh inventory?
Mid-week is usually best — shops process weekend buy-ins on Monday and Tuesday, so by Wednesday the singles binders and showcase cases have new pulls.
Are there baseball card shops that buy collections?
Nearly all do. Bring a list of your top cards (player, year, condition, set), plus photos for anything you think is valuable. Call ahead for large estates.

Explore the full card collecting FAQ →

Stay In The Loop

SUBSCRIBE TO OUR
NEWSLETTER

New shop listings, card show dates, hobby news, and exclusive collector insights — delivered to your inbox. No spam, just cardboard.

I collect:

Free forever · Unsubscribe anytime · No spam