Retro Replay

The Provo mall's retro game and card counter, best known for hosting a monthly Pokemon card show that fills the concourse with vendor tables and raffles.

Retro Replay earns its place on a Provo card shop list less for what sits on the shelf on a Tuesday and more for what happens in the mall concourse once a month. The store runs a recurring Pokemon card show at Provo Towne Centre with vendor tables, live raffles and giveaways spread across the afternoon, floor access typically running to 9PM, and turnout that pulls collectors from across Utah Valley. If you want to buy, sell and trade Pokemon cards in Provo in volume, the show is the single best day on the local calendar.

Day to day, the storefront is a used media operation — retro consoles and cartridges across every generation, modern discs, DVDs and VHS — with trading cards as a real but secondary line. Go in with accurate expectations and it is a rewarding stop; go in expecting a glass case of graded slabs and it is not.

Trade-in economics are what regulars actually praise. Multiple reviewers describe the buy prices as the fairest in Utah Valley, with one calling it the most honest used game store in the area specifically because the payouts match or beat the competition without haggling. The counterweight is condition: critical reviews focus hard on scuffed discs and dusty stock, and the 3.6 average reflects a genuinely split customer base rather than middling indifference. Inspect before you buy and you will do fine.

Hours are 11AM to 8PM Monday through Thursday, 11AM to 9PM Friday and Saturday, and noon to 6PM Sunday — the only Provo card shop on this directory open on Sundays. Mall parking is free, and the suite sits on the lower level, a short walk from We Geek Together upstairs, which makes a single Towne Centre trip cover two very different corners of the local hobby.