Thirty years of sports card inventory packed into a second-floor South Willow room, from dollar commons to slabbed rookies, plus Pokemon and DBS.
Quinns is the shop people mean when they say they want a real sports card store. Family owned, more than thirty years in the business, and stacked into a second-floor space on South Willow Street where the browsing genuinely does eat an afternoon. Every sport, every era, and a price ladder that starts at a dollar and climbs into the graded cases without ever feeling like two different stores.
The sports inventory is the draw: baseball, football, basketball, and hockey across modern and vintage, boxes and packs for people who would rather rip than buy singles, and slabs in the case for the collectors chasing a specific grade. The shop leans into the rip culture openly, and the counter is happy to pull something down and open it with you.
Alongside the sports material there is a genuine Pokemon section, plus Dragon Ball Super and Flesh and Blood, so the shop is not a one-category stop. Supplies are stocked too, which matters more than it sounds when you have just pulled something out of a box and need a sleeve before it leaves the room.
Owner reputation carries this listing. Reviews describe a massive selection across every sport and a proprietor who is, in one customer's words, a wicked nice guy. If you are trying to work out what a collection is actually worth, this is a good room to have that conversation in.
One planning note before you drive over: the shop keeps short hours, 10am to 6pm Tuesday through Friday and 10am to 5pm Saturday, with Sunday and Monday closed. The entrance is on the second floor of the South Willow building, so look for the interior stairs rather than a ground-level door.
