Top Magic: The Gathering Card Shops
Highest-rated shops in our directory carrying Magic: The Gathering singles and sealed product.
The Game Preserve
346 reviews
⭐ Top Rated
8487 Union Chapel Rd, Ste 660, Indianapolis, IN
Hours
10AM–9PM
Clever Bay Sports & Gaming
103 reviews
900 Tutor Ln, Evansville, IN
Hours
12PM-6PM
Paradigm Games
40 reviews
2479 N Meridian St, Indianapolis, IN
Hours
Closed today
Griffon Bookstore
517 reviews
121 W Colfax Ave, South Bend, IN
Hours
10AM-6PM
Common Room Games
200 reviews
223 S Pete Ellis Dr, Bloomington, IN
Hours
12PM-10PM
Card Craze
100 reviews
4629 W Richland Plaza Dr, Bloomington, IN
Hours
12PM-8PM
The Gaming Guild
453 reviews
1460 N Green River Rd, Evansville, IN
Hours
11AM-9PM
Main Phase One
45 reviews
840 East Diamond Ave, Evansville, IN
Hours
10AM-9PM
Fantasy Games
618 reviews
52025 State Hwy 933, South Bend, IN
Hours
12PM-10PM
The Game Preserve Southside
218 reviews
1551 E Stop 12 Rd, Ste B, Indianapolis, IN
Hours
10AM–9PM
Gray Gauntlet Games
87 reviews
7998 Centerpoint Dr, Ste 750, Indianapolis, IN
Hours
Closed today
Summit Sports, Comics & Games
60 reviews
4240 W Jefferson Blvd Ste M-8, Fort Wayne, IN
Hours
10AM-9PM
Good Games Indianapolis
439 reviews
111 S Meridian St, Indianapolis, IN
Hours
11AM-9PM
K & L Cards
96 reviews
3100 Meridian Parke Dr, Ste Z, Greenwood, IN
Hours
11AM–6PM
Grandmaster Games
400 reviews
7307 US-31 Suite A, Indianapolis, IN
Hours
12PM-7PM
The Dugout
182 reviews
5707 W Morris St, Indianapolis, IN
Hours
12PM–7PM
Infinite TCG
105 reviews
1509 Goshen Ave, Fort Wayne, IN
Hours
12PM-7PM